Abstract:Building Services Engineering Research and Technology, Ahead of Print. Developing appropriate building retrofit strategies is a challenging task. This case study presents a multi-criteria decision-supporting method that suggests optimal solutions and alternative design references with a range of diversity at the early exploration stage in building retrofit. This method employs a practical two-step method to identify critical comfort and energy issues and generate optimised design options with multi-objective optimisation based on a genetic algorithm. The first step is based on a post-occupancy evaluation, which cross-refers benchmarking and correlation and integrates them with non-linear satisfaction theory to extract critical comfort factors. The second step parameterises previous outputs as objectives to conduct building simulation practice. The case study is a typical post-war highly glazed open-plan office in London. The post-occupancy evaluation result identifies direct sunlight glare, indoor temperature, and noise from other occupants as critical comfort factors. The simulation and optimisation extract the optimal retrofit strategies by analysing 480 generated Pareto fronts. The proposed method provides retrofit solutions with a criteria-based filtering method and considers the trade-off between the energy and comfort objectives. The method can be transformed into a design-supporting tool to identify the key comfort factors for built environment optimisation and create sustainability in building retrofit.Practical application: This study suggested that statistical analysis could be integrated with parametric design tools and multi-objective optimisation. It directly links users' subjective opinions to the final design solutions, suggesting a new method for data-driven generative design. As a quantitative process, the proposed framework could be automated with a program, reducing the human effort in the optimisation process and reducing the reliance on human experience in the design question defining and analysis process. It might also avoid human mistakes, e.g. overlooking some critical factors. During the multi-objective optimisation process, large numbers of design options are generated, and many of them are optimised at the Pareto front. Exploring these options could be a less human effort-intensive process than designing completely new options, especially in the early design exploration phase. Overall, this might be a potential direction for future study in generative design, which greatly reduce the technical obstacle of sustainable design for high building performance.

The use of an analytic hierarchy process to evaluate the flexibility and adaptability in architecture

Flexibility and Adaptability of the Living Space to the Changing Needs of Residents

Adaptability Evaluation of Historic Buildings As an Approach to Propose Adaptive Reuse Strategies Based on Complex Adaptive System Theory

Adaptability in healthcare buildings: a perspective through Joseph Bracops Hospital

MULTI-CRITERIA ANALYSIS IN THE MANAGEMENT OF TEMPORARY REUSE OF SPACES

Enhancing Software Architecture Adaptability: A Comprehensive Evaluation Method

Flexibility and sustainability factor in unorganized and organized types of urban environment

BIM-enabled Multi-Level Assessment of Age-Friendliness of Urban Housing Based on Multiscale Spatial Framework: Enlightenments of Housing Support for “Aging-in-place”

Solving the comfort-retrofit conundrum through post-occupancy evaluation and multi-objective optimisation

Integrating requirement analysis and multi-objective optimization for office building energy retrofit strategies

Industrial Heritage Rethinking: Flexibility Design for Eco-Friendly Environments

Evaluation of learning methods in architecture design studio via analytic hierarchy process: a case study

Architectural Design: Sustainability in the Decision-Making Process

A Study on the Adpatability Design Strategy of Eco-Architecture

Evaluation of subsidized housing, case study in Deçan

Multicriteria assessment of landscape architecture projects: the sustainability perspective

Integration of life-cycle assessment in a multimodal building design approach

Adapting for shared use – evaluating the lifecycle carbon impact

Green Scale Research Tool for Multi-Criteria and Multi-Metric Energy Analysis Performed During the Architectural Design Process

Housing and neighbourhood diagnosis for ageing in place: Multidimensional Assessment System of the Built Environment (MASBE)

An Interactive Multi-criteria Decision-making Method for Building Performance Design