A Multi-Level Study of Employee Voice:Evidence from a Chain of Retail Stores in China
Liang Jian,Tang Jing
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2009.03.016
2009-01-01
Abstract:With rapid changes in technology and business environ-ments,employees are becoming invaluable assets for organizations,not only for their physical labor,but also for their innovative ideas.Despite the desirability of employee voice in the workplace,employ-ees often feel uncomfortable about openly expressing themselves on organizational issues(Dutton,Ashford,O'Neill,Hayes,& Wierba,1997;Milliken,Morrison,& Hewlin,2003).Therefore,it is important to know how to create supportive environments where people can express themselves.Employing a multi-level design,we examine the combined influence of organizational characteristics(e.g.,transfor-mational leadership and supportive peer relations)and individual attributes(e.g.,proactive personality)on individual voice behavior and the collective voice climate at both the organizational and individual level.Furthermore,we link both individual voice behavior and the collective voice climate with individual and organizational level performance measures.Finally,we hypothesize two cross-level effects:the regulating effects of organizational characteristics on the relation-ship between proactive personality and individual voice behavior,and the top-down influence of the collective voice climate on individual creative performance.Data collected from a domestic chain of retail stores are used to examine the multi-level hypotheses.Two hundred and sixty-seven employees from fifty-nine independent stores par-ticipated in this study.The results offer support for individual level relationships between proactive personality,individual voice behav-ior,and creative performance.But at the organizational level,we only find a positive impact of transformational leadership on the collective voice climate within a store.Both the two cross-level hypotheses received support.The results suggest a negative cross-level interac-tion between proactive personality and transformation leadership for individual voice behavior.The interaction plot shows that the positive effect of transformational leadership on individual voice behavior is stronger for less proactive employees than those with a proactive dis-position.In addition,there is a strong positive top-down effect of the collective voice climate on individual creative performance.At the end of this paper,we discuss the implications for management theory and practice in a Chinese context.