Abstract:Researchers investigating relationships between the neighbourhood environment and health first need to decide on the spatial extent of the neighbourhood they are interested in. This decision is an important and ongoing methodological challenge since different methods of defining and delineating neighbourhood boundaries can produce different results. This paper explores this issue in the context of a New Zealand-based study of the relationship between the built environment and multiple measures of physical activity. Geographic information systems were used to measure three built environment attributes—dwelling density, street connectivity, and neighbourhood destination accessibility—using seven different neighbourhood definitions (three administrative unit boundaries, and 500, 800, 1000- and 1500-m road network buffers). The associations between the three built environment measures and five measures of physical activity (mean accelerometer counts per hour, percentage time in moderate–vigorous physical activity, self-reported walking for transport, self-reported walking for recreation and self-reported walking for all purposes) were modelled for each neighbourhood definition. The combination of the choice of neighbourhood definition, built environment measure, and physical activity measure determined whether evidence of an association was detected or not. Results demonstrated that, while there was no single ideal neighbourhood definition, the built environment was most consistently associated with a range of physical activity measures when the 800-m and 1000-m road network buffers were used. For the street connectivity and destination accessibility measures, associations with physical activity were less likely to be detected at smaller scales (less than 800 m). In line with some previous research, this study demonstrated that the choice of neighbourhood definition can influence whether or not an association between the built environment and adults’ physical activity is detected or not. This study additionally highlighted the importance of the choice of built environment attribute and physical activity measures. While we identified the 800-m and 1000-m road network buffers as the neighbourhood definitions most consistently associated with a range of physical activity measures, it is important that researchers carefully consider the most appropriate type of neighbourhood definition and scale for the particular aim and participants, especially at smaller scales.

The Relationship of Physical Activity and the Built Environment within the Context of Self-Determination Theory

Is the relationship between the built environment and physical activity moderated by perceptions of crime and safety?

Individual, Social, Environmental, and Physical Environmental Correlates with Physical Activity among Canadians: a Cross-Sectional Study

The Relationship between the Physical Activity Environment, Nature Relatedness, Anxiety, and the Psychological Well-being Benefits of Regular Exercisers

A Self-Determination Theory Approach for Exercise Motivation in Rural Dwelling Older Adults

Psychological needs and exercise behaviour: a comparison of two psychological needs models

Sports Facilities, Shopping Centers or Homes: What Locations are Important for Adults’ Physical Activity? A Cross-Sectional Study

In search of causality: a systematic review of the relationship between the built environment and physical activity among adults

Perceived environment attributes, residential location, and walking for particular purposes

The relationship between physical activity and the living environment: a multi-level analyses focusing on changes over time in environmental factors

A Longitudinal Theory-Based Investigation of how Environmental Aesthetics predicts Home-based Exercise

Objectively-assessed neighbourhood destination accessibility and physical activity in adults from 10 countries: An analysis of moderators and perceptions as mediators

The Relationship of Exercise, Psychosocial Factors, and Social Participation Among Adults Aging With Long-Term Physical Disability: A Cross-Sectional Study

Social and environmental determinants of physical activity in urban parks: Testing a neighborhood disorder model

Association between perceived built environmental attributes and physical activity among adults in South Africa

The Relationship between Physical Activity and the Objectively-Measured Built Environment in Low- and High-Income South African Communities

Investigating Differences in Personality Traits, Self-Esteem, Eating Attitudes, and Body Image among Participants in Indoor and Outdoor Fitness Activities

The Role of the Perceived Neighborhood Social Environment on Adolescent Sedentary Behavior and Physical Activity: Findings from Add Health

Perceived neighborhood environment walkability and health-related quality of life among predominantly Black and Latino adults in New York City

How Do Neighbourhood Definitions Influence the Associations between Built Environment and Physical Activity?

Psychosocial factors of physical activity among people with disabilities: Prospective cohort study.