Validity of Rogerian Therapy in Turkish Culture: A Cross-Cultural Perspective.
Şenel Poyrazlı
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/J.2164-490X.2003.TB00172.X
2003-03-01
Abstract:Rogerian therapy is highly regarded and popular in Turkey. The model, however, represents individualistic Western culture. In this article, the author focuses on and discusses the validity of the model in Turkish culture and provides suggestions for counseling Turkish clients. ********** Theories of counseling and psychotherapy reflect the cultures and societies in which they are developed. Major developments in this profession originated in the United States. As a result, these theories represent individualistic Western or U.S. culture (Kagitcibasi, 1994). Western culture encourages individuals to be unique and independent and to express themselves. Third World traditional cultures, on the other hand, value dependence and encourage individuals to fit in the social groups (Triandis, McCusker, & Hui, 1990). Because of these cultural differences, the validity of U.S. counseling psychology in a developing traditional country, such as Turkey, is questionable (Skovholt, 1988; Sundel-Hansen, 1985). Western psychology and psychotherapy have a great influence on psychotherapy applications in Turkey (Kagitcibasi, 1994; Ongel & Smith, 1999). Rogerian therapy, which was developed in the United States, is highly regarded and popular in Turkey (McWhirter, 1983). The model was developed for clients of a middle-class culture who have a reasonable amount of verbal fluency. Turkish culture is predominantly Islamic. The people of an Islamic background are often unfamiliar with behavioral patterns that seem to be obvious and normal in Western culture (Deen, 1985). In addition, unlike Western culture, Turkish people are apt to communicate through nonverbal communication such as gestures and symbols (McWhirter, 1983). People from Third World traditional cultures grow up in a climate in which the adult authority cannot be contradicted and has absolute validity. In a counseling session, the client from this culture expects the counselor (i.e., the authority) to guide, probe, and provide structure. Rogerian counseling, on the other hand, is a nondirective approach in which the counselor avoids directing or structuring the counseling session (Deen, 1985). As a result, people from a traditional Turkish culture may be disappointed and may not benefit from Rogerian therapy. In this article, I focus on the validity of the application of Rogerian therapy in Turkish culture. Before the discussion, however, it is important to present an overview of Rogerian therapy and of Turkish culture so that the discussion can be easily followed. AN OVERVIEW OF ROGERIAN THERAPY The focus of Rogerian therapy, also known as client-centered therapy, is an actualizing tendency that is present in every human being. Actualizing tendency refers to the inclination of individuals to achieve their potentials, capacities, and talents. This actualization develops in a positive and constructive manner only if a climate of acceptance, respect, and trust is established. According to Rogerian theory, individuals have within themselves the necessary resources for personal growth and are motivated to develop their full potential (Rice & Greenberg, 1991; Rogers, 1951). Individuals, however, may encounter obstacles in their environment that hinder their personal growth (Rice & Greenberg, 1991). The primary goal of Rogerian therapy is to release the actualizing tendency by assisting the client in overcoming obstacles. To achieve this goal, the counselor avoids structuring or directing the counseling process. Instead, the counselor offers himself or herself as a nonjudgmental person (Corey, 1991). Rogerian therapy values the relationship between client and counselor and states that in order to build a good relationship, the Rogerian therapist should embody three characteristics: (a) Congruence, or genuineness; (b) unconditional positive regard and acceptance; and (c) empathy. These three characteristics, or attitudes, of the Rogerian therapist form a central part of the therapeutic relationship. …
Psychology