Abstract:The way high school chemistry curricula are structured has the potential to convey consequential messages about knowledge and knowing to students and teachers. If a curriculum is built around practicing skills and recalling facts to reach “correct” answers, it is unlikely class activities will be seen (by students or the teacher) as opportunities to figure out causes for phenomena. Our team of teachers and researchers is working to understand how enactment of transformed curricular materials can support high school chemistry students in making sense of perplexing, relatable phenomena. Given this goal, we were surprised to see that co-developers who enacted our materials overwhelmingly emphasized the importance of acquiring true facts/skills when writing weekly reflections. Recognition that teachers’ expressed aims did not align with our stated goal of “supporting molecular-level sensemaking” led us to examine whether the tacit epistemological commitments reflected by our materials were, in fact, consistent with a course focused on figuring out phenomena. We described several aspects of each lesson in our two-semester curriculum including: the role of phenomena in lesson activities, the extent to which lessons were 3-dimensional, the role of student ideas in class dialogue, and who established coherence between lessons. Triangulation of these lesson features enabled us to infer messages about valued knowledge products and processes materials had the potential to send. We observed that our materials commonly encouraged students to mimic the structure of science practices for the purpose of being evaluated by the teacher. That is, students were asked to “go through the motions” of explaining, modeling etc. but had little agency regarding the sorts of models and explanations they found productive in their class community. This study serves to illustrate the importance of surfacing the tacit epistemological commitments that guide curriculum development. Additionally, it extends existing scholarship on epistemological messaging by considering curricular materials as a potentially consequential sources of messages.

Introducing a Culture of Modeling To Enhance Conceptual Understanding in High School Chemistry Courses

The Impact of Core-Idea Centered Instruction on High School Students’ Understanding of Structure–Property Relationships

Construction and Practice of Precision Teaching Model Incorporating “big Idea”: Take the “plants and Soil” Unit As an Example

Applying the VisChem Approach in High School Classrooms: Chemical Learning Outcomes and Limitations

Metamodeling Knowledge: Developing Students' Understanding of Scientific Modeling

Introducing high school biology students to biochemistry with a short, content-oriented module

Narrative-Based Concept Representations: Fostering Visual Cognition in the Introductory Chemistry Classroom

Modeling Scientific Processes with Mathematics Equations Enhances Student Qualitative Conceptual Understanding and Quantitative Problem Solving.

Creating Meaningful Learning Opportunities through Incorporating Local Research into Chemistry Classroom Activities

Applying flipped classroom model in teaching Organic Chemistry in grade 11 to develop the self-study capacity of students at high schools

Conceptual Change in Science Teaching and Learning: Introducing the Dynamic Model of Conceptual Change

Chemistry and the Next Generation Science Standards

Modeling as a teaching learning process for understanding materials: A case study in primary education

A Novel Modelling Process in Chemistry: Merging Biological and Mathematical Perspectives to Develop Modelling Competences

Transforming High School Physics with Modeling and Computation

Progression toward Causal Mechanistic Reasoning through Phenomenon-Based Learning in Introductory Chemistry

Messages about valued knowledge products and processes embedded within a suite of transformed high school chemistry curricular materials

Learning electrochemistry through scientific inquiry. Conceptual modelling as learning objective and as scaffold

EMMAs: Implementation and Assessment of a Suite of Cross-Disciplinary, Case-Based High School Activities to Explore Three-Dimensional Molecular Structure, Noncovalent Interactions, and Molecular Dynamics

Designing context-based teaching materials by transforming authentic scientific modelling practices in chemistry