Abstract:The rapid development of the electricity industry reform in China has been witnessed in recent years, and one of the iconic achievements could be the establishment and trial operation of the electricity spot markets. However, even though the market clearing model for electric energy is identical to that adopted in the mature markets in the U.S., which has been widely confirmed to respect the principle of incentive compatibility, some special features are instead observed regarding the offering behaviors of generators, indicating the inconsistency with the principle of incentive compatibility. Therefore, an in-depth study on the causes for the observed features is of urgent significance, and corresponding potential modifications on the market mechanism are anticipated. This paper firstly establishes an equilibrium analysis model for the electric energy and frequency regulation ancillary service (FRAS) markets, based on the real-world practice in China. By providing the optimal offering strategies of the generators at the equilibrium point, the equilibrium analysis could shed light on the causes for the observed features on the offering behaviors. Then, the paper proposes potential modifications on the market mechanism considering the real institutional and operational characteristics in China, with proposing a multi-objective optimization model and a decentralized algorithm for market clearing, as well as giving full consideration to the availability of FRAS. Finally, the feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed model and algorithm are justified by case studies. The results demonstrate that the proposed modifications could achieve the identical objective of realizing the minimum system costs as the existing market mechanism adopted in the U.S., and be more adaptive to the real institutional and operational characteristics in China. Policy recommendations are also presented for the establishment and operation of the electricity spot markets in China.

Research on the Trading Arrangement and Clearing Model of Medium- and Long-Term Inter-Provincial Markets Considering Security Constraints

Incentive-Compatible Market Clearing for a Two-Stage Integrated Electricity-Gas-Heat Market

Low Carbon and Efficiency Oriented Day-Ahead Joint Electrical Energy and Ancillary Services Market Clearing Model for Generation-Side in China

The Design of Provincial Ancillary Service Markets in China under the New-Round Electric Power Industry Reform

Research on China’s New Energy Cross-Provincial Marketization Mechanism under the Background of “double Carbon”

Bi-Level Electricity Market Design with Boundary Equivalence of Interior Security Constraints

Research on Centralized Optimization Clearing Method for Interregional Spot Market

A Mechanism for Two-Level Power Market in China: Promoting Cross Regional Consumption of Renewable Energy

Research on Provincial Regulation Ancillary Service Market of China under the New Round of Electricity Reform

Bilaterally Open Electricity Markets with High Penetration of Renewables

Research on cross-provincial power trading strategy considering the medium and long-term trading plan

Impact of Different Bidding Methods for New Energy Units on Clearing Results of Electricity Spot Market

Development of Energy and Reserve Pre-Dispatch and Re-Dispatch Models for Real-Time Price Risk and Reliability Assessment

Study on the electricity spot market trading mechanism considering the proportion of renewable energy consumption quota

A day-ahead electricity market-clearing model considering medium- and long-term transactions and wind producer participation

Research on Regional Spot Market Clearing Model Considering Subregional Power Exchange Constraints

The equilibrium analysis and potential modifications on the China pilot electricity spot market

A Collaborative Generation-Side Clearing Model for Generation Company in Coupled Energy, Ancillary Service and Carbon Emission Trading Market in China

Power Trading Region Considering Long-Term Contract for Interconnected Power Networks

Study on the bi-level optimal clearing model of electricity market considering the weight of consumption responsibility

Increasing Renewable Energy Consumption Coordination with the Monthly Interprovincial Transaction Market