Abstract:Despite ambitions in development and global health policy to transform communities into supportive environments for women facing risks of violence, our understanding of how to best engage communities remains incomplete. In particular, there is little evidence on the types of strategies that communities employ to address violence against women (VAW). We aimed to describe and analyse the processes involved in community responses to incidents of VAW in a non-governmental organisation (NGO) violence prevention programme in Mumbai, India. We conducted a grounded theory study involving 30 focus group discussions and 36 semi-structured interviews with 113 community members and 9 NGO staff, as well as over 170 h of field observation. Informed by comparative case study methods, we compared community actions across six informal settlement neighbourhoods. We found considerable variation in the type of action taken across neighbourhoods. This variation was not arbitrary, but reflected systematic cost-benefit considerations in heterogeneous environments, accounting for factors such as trust in neighbours, violent (armed or gang-related) crime, and corruption in state institutions. We found that institutional action was only favoured in neighbourhoods with strong state capacity and high social capital, whilst remedial action—resolving violence through 'private' talks in the family and community—and radical action involving extra-judicial violence—became favourable under conditions of weak social capital or low state capacity. Institutional action was, however, sometimes as violent as radical action, as police were reported, sometimes even relied upon, by residents to use force against perpetrators of VAW. We argue that these contextual features oblige policymakers and prevention researchers to grapple with contentious issues such as the legitimate use of force by the state. We caution against maximising community action without a clear vision of the type of action hoped for.

Questions of honour: Dalit women activists and the rumour mill in Tamil Nadu

Gender, Caste and Subjectivity: Revisiting the #MeToo Movement in India

Problematising Testimony in Autobiographical Narratives by Dalit Women in the English Translation

Caste and Gender Politics: An Understanding of Dalit Consciousness in the Poems of Contemporary Dalit Writers

'Our courage has grown': a grounded theory study of enablers and barriers to community action to address violence against women in urban India

Constructions of Honor-Based Violence: Gender, Context and Orientalism

Social Psychological Explorations of Caste: Unravelling Challenges and Discovering Opportunities

The crime vanishes: Mob lynching, hate crime, and police discretion in India

Contending with Carcerality: Discursive Resistance to Elite Appropriation of Antiviolence Activism in Indian Media

Rumour and gossip in a time of crisis: Resistance and accommodation in a South Indian plantation frontier

The #metoo Movement in India: Emotions and (in)justice in feminist responses

Interrogating Intersectionality: The Me-Too Movement in India

Disrupting Anxious Masculinity: Fraternity as Resistance

Vains of Ink and Blood: The Cost of Truth for Fearless Women

Caste and gender in Tamil cinema: phallic rehabilitation in the neo-native film Dharma Durai

Remedial, institutional or radical? Explaining community responses to violence against women in an NGO programme to prevent violence in Mumbai, India

Representation of Feminism in African American and Dalit Literature

A mixed-methods approach to understand victimization discourses by opposing feminist sub-groups on social media

The Cauxin-femme binary: Femme performativity as a response to violence in Guyana

Chords of solidarity, notes of dissent: the role of feminist conferences in movement-building in India

A Review on Status of Dalit Women in Koderma