Abstract:Escalation of drug use, a hallmark of drug dependence, has traditionally been interpreted as reflecting the development of tolerance to the drug's effects. However, on the basis of animal behavioral data, several groups have recently proposed alternative explanations, i.e. that such an escalation of drug use might not be based on (1) tolerance, but rather be indicative of (2) sensitization to the drug's reinforcing effect, (3) reward allostasis, (4) an increase in the incentive salience of drug-associated stimuli, (5) an increase in the reinforcing strength of the drug reinforcer relative to alternative reinforcers, or (6) habit formation. From the pharmacological perspective, models 1-3 allow predictions about the change in the shape of drug dose-effect curves that are based on mathematically defined models governing receptor-ligand interaction and signal transduction. These predictions are tested in the present review, which also describes the other currently championed models for drug use escalation and other components of apparent 'reinforcement' (in its original meaning, like 'tolerance' or 'sensitization', a purely descriptive term). It evaluates the animal experimental approaches employed to support or prove the existence of each of the models and reinforcement components, and recapitulates the clinical evidence, which strongly suggests that escalation of drug use is predominantly based on an increase in the frequency of intoxication events rather than an increase in the dose taken at each intoxication event. Two apparent discrepancies in animal experiments are that (a) sensitization to overall reinforcement has been found more often for psychostimulants than for opioids, and that (b) tolerance to the reinforcing and other effects has been observed more often for opioids than for cocaine. These discrepancies are resolved by the finding that cocaine levels seem to be more tightly regulated at submaximum reinforcing levels than opioid levels are. Consequently, animals self-administering opioids are more likely to expose themselves to higher above-threshold doses than animals self-administering psychostimulants, rendering the development of tolerance to opioids more likely than tolerance to psychostimulants. The review concludes by making suggestions on how to improve the current behavioral experimental approaches.

Punishment models of addictive behavior

Understanding sex differences and the translational value of models of persistent substance use despite negative consequences

Seeking under threat of adversity: assessing control over reward pursuit in rats

Advances in understanding meso-cortico-limbic-striatal systems mediating risky reward seeking

Compulsive Drug-Taking is Associated with Habenula–frontal Cortex Connectivity

Behavioral and neurobiological mechanisms of punishment: implications for psychiatric disorders

Animal Models of Drug Relapse and Craving after Voluntary Abstinence: A Review

Compulsive Drug Use is Associated with Imbalance of Orbitofrontal- and Prelimbic-Striatal Circuits in Punishment-Resistant Individuals

Human laboratory models of reward in substance use disorder

Role of serotonin neurons in the dorsal raphe nucleus in heroin self-administration and punishment

Animal models of compulsion alcohol drinking: Why we love quinine-resistant intake and what we learned from it

A mathematical model of reward-mediated learning in drug addiction

Delay of punishment highlights differential vulnerability to developing addiction-like behavior toward sweet food

A Novel Method to Study Reward-Context Associations and Drug-Seeking Behaviors

Dopamine, behavior, and addiction

Involvement of Learning and Memory in the Development of Addictive Be-Havior and the Related Brain Mechanism

Animal models for studying therapeutic targets and treatments for alcohol use disorder

The Role of Stress in Opiate and Psychostimulant Addiction: Evidence from Animal Models

Modelling Human Drug Abuse and Addiction with Dedicated Small Animal Positron Emission Tomography

Explaining the Escalation of Drug Use in Substance Dependence: Models and Appropriate Animal Laboratory Tests

Improving translation of animal models of addiction and relapse by reverse translation