The burden of the knowledge-to-action gap in acute appendicitis
Stefano Piero Bernardo Cioffi,Michele Altomare,Mauro Podda,Andrea Spota,Stefano Granieri,Elisa Reitano,Beatrice Zamburlini,Francesco Virdis,Roberto Bini,Shailvi Gupta,Guido Torzilli,Andrea Mingoli,Osvaldo Chiara,Stefania Cimbanassi,REsiDENT-1 research group,Giulia Arianna Abruzzese,Francesca Albanesi,Erika Andreatta,Ludovica Baldari,Laura Benuzzi,Emanuele Bevilaqua,Alessandro Michele Bonomi,Greta Brachetti,Giulia Cannavale,Andrea Piero Chierici,Riccardo Cirelli,Gaia Colletti,Vera D'abrosca,Piergiorgio Danelli,Luca Del Prete,Francesco Di Capua,Francesca Di Vittorio,Davide Ferrari,Luca Ferrario,Laura Fiore,Colomba Frattaruolo,Caterina Froiio,Ludovica Gibelli,Irene Giusti,Ugo Giustizieri,Samuele Grandi,Giulio Iacob,Alessia Kersik,Pietro Lombardi,Marco Longhi,Leonardo Lorusso,Michele Manara,Elena Manzo,Jacopo Nicolo Marin,Marianna Maspero,Valentina Messina,Pamela Milito,Mattia Molteni,Eleonora Monti,Vincenzo Nicastro,Giorgio Novelli,Sissi Paleino,Silvia Pavesi,Carolina Perali,Isabella Pezzoli,Roberta Ragozzino,Giuliano Santolamazza,Luca Scaravilli,Gilda Tornatore,Francesco Toti,Vincenzo Tripodi,Elisa Vaterlini,Barbara Vignati,Cecilia Maina,Alessandra Borghi,Marco Realis Luc,Paolo Pizzini,Riccardo Masserano,Marta Maistri,Laura Traballi,Francesco Cammarata,Alvino Boero,Davide Socci,Margherita Carbonaro,Martina Pellegrini
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00464-023-10449-4
Abstract:Background: The burden of emergency general surgery (EGS) is higher compared to elective surgery. Acute appendicitis (AA) is one of the most frequent diseases and its management is dictated by published international clinical practice guidelines (CPG). Adherence to CPG has been reported as heterogeneous. Barriers to clinical implementation were not studied. This study explored barriers to adherence to CPG and the clinico-economic impact of poor compliance. Methods: Data were extracted from the three-year data lock of the REsiDENT-1 registry, a prospective resident-led multicenter trial. We identified 7 items from CPG published from the European Association of Endoscopic Surgery (EAES) and the World Society of Emergency Surgery (WSES). We applied our classification proposal and used a five-point Likert scale (Ls) to assess laparoscopic appendectomy (LA) difficulty. Descriptive analyses were performed to explore compliance and group comparisons to assess the impact on outcomes and related costs. We ran logistic regressions to identify barriers and facilitators to implementation of CPG. Results: From 2019 to 2022, 653 LA were included from 24 centers. 69 residents performed and coordinated data collection. We identified low compliance with recommendations on peritoneal irrigation (PI) (25.73%), abdominal drains (AD) (34.68%), and antibiotic stewardship (34.17%). Poor compliance on PI and AD was associated to higher infectious complications in uncomplicated AA. Hospitalizations were significantly longer in non-compliance except for PI in uncomplicated AA, and costs significantly higher, exception made for antibiotic stewardship in complicated AA. The strongest barriers to CPG implementation were complicated AA and technically challenging LA for PI and AD. Longer operative times and the use of PI negatively affected antibiotic stewardship in uncomplicated AA. Compliance was higher in teaching hospitals and in emergency surgery units. Conclusions: We confirmed low compliance with standardized items influenced by environmental factors and non-evidence-based practices in complex LA. Antibiotic stewardship is sub-optimal. Not following CPG may not influence clinical complications but has an impact in terms of logistics, costs and on the non-measurable magnitude of antibiotic resistance. Structured educational interventions and institutional bundles are required.