Abstract:Theory: Medical curricula now include more time for trainees to manage their studying independently, yet evidence suggests that time is not well spent without guidance. Social-cognitivist models of self-regulated learning suggest value when guiding learners to set goals related to their performance processes (actions producing outcomes) versus their performance outcomes (products of performance). Hypotheses: We expected participants oriented to set process goals would demonstrate better suturing skill retention compared with participants oriented to set outcome goals. Method: We randomly assigned 41 medical students to two groups: outcome oriented or process oriented. They self-scored their performance using a visual analog scale on every third trial during 25 training trials, and during 10 retention trials 2 weeks later. Two raters assessed participants' suturing performances (process) and final products (outcome). After finding weak support for our hypothesis, we calculated a "self-monitoring calibration coefficient" as the Pearson's correlation between the raters' average score and each participant's self-scores. We used a mixed-effects analysis of variance to compare participants' performance scores as well as t tests and an analysis of variance to compare their self-monitoring calibration coefficients. Results: Analysis of skill retention data revealed a significant Group × Trial interaction, suggesting a benefit for the process group only for the 10th retention trial (p = .03). During training, the process group had significantly better (p = .02) self-monitoring calibration (r = .71 ± .29) than the outcome group (r = .38 ± .55). In retention, participants in both groups were significantly better calibrated (p = .04) with rater's scores of performance processes (r = .39 ± .60) versus performance outcomes (r = .11 ± .63). Conclusions: Our findings provide limited evidence for our original hypothesis. Perhaps more important, however, our self-monitoring calibration data highlighted inconsistencies between our interventions and our participants' apparent preferences. Not all participants adopted their assigned goal setting orientation, showing that researchers and educators must consider the extent to which trainees adopt imposed instructions in any educational intervention.

Goal Setting: Effective Strategies to Plan for a Successful Career

Goal-setting in the career management process: An identity theory perspective.

Ready, Set, Goal: A Mixed Methods Study of a Goal-Setting Intervention on 2 Competency-Based Geriatric Medicine Rotations

Give It to Me Straight Doc: A Medical Student Perspective on Effective Goal-Oriented Clinical Education

Career management: an active process.

Self-goal setting as a way to career sustainability: exploring the roles of career crafting and perceived organizational goal clarity

Self-regulation of health behavior: Social psychological approaches to goal setting and goal striving.

Perceptions of goal setting in a neurological rehabilitation unit: a qualitative study of patients, carers and staff

Mentorship for Non-academic, Mid-Career Hospitalist Physicians: The Journey Taken Less Often

Develop Your CORE2 for Career Flourishing: A Career Development Workshop for Hospitalists

Design and Implementation of a Career Guidance Program at Gachon University College of Medicine

Assigning Medical Students Learning Goals: Do They Do It, and What Happens When They Don't?

Person-Centered, Goal-Oriented Care Helped My Patients Improve Their Quality of Life

Goal‐setting in geriatric rehabilitation: Can the nursing profession meet patients' needs? A narrative review

Lifelong development in medicine: a thematic analysis of coaching goals throughout medical careers

Identifying Professional Goals and Promoting Career Development in Nursing Students Through Reflection and Simulation

Self-goal setting and career sustainability research from China explores roles of career crafting and perceived organizational goal clarity

New Directions in Goal-Setting Theory

Finding the Right Mentor

Goal Instability in Relation to Career Thoughts, Decision State, and Performance in a Career Course

An exploratory study of goal orientations of traditional block and longitudinal integrated clerkship students