Abstract:In his popular 1806 lectures on religion Fichte considered five possible worldviews in the second of which, “the standpoint of legality”, one can readily recognise the ethics of law of the Stoical and Kantian type. Fichte stresses that in his youth he himself shared this worldview. However, he hastens to adduce a series of original arguments to show that this position is essentially incapable of delivering a pure and higher moral doctrine. I examine the substance of these critical arguments in the context of his later metaphysics. Fichte maintains that in the “second type” of worldview man himself feels and understands, respects and loves himself only as a subject of unconditional law, therefore the pathos and “affection of law” pervades all his assessments and motivations. This affects the impartiality of moral assessment if the requirements of the law are diverged from. The “man of law”, the Stoic and Kantian who is not conscious of direct violations of the law, can at most not despise himself, but he cannot, according to Fichte, positively respect himself: that would require surpassing the requirement of the law through action. Meanwhile the affection of the self-sufficient law conceals even this impossibility from such a person. Finally, I show that the ethics of the Stoical and Kantian type retains, according to Fichte’s diagnosis, a refined interest in preserving and indulging the sensual self and hence the idea of God as the warrantor of empirical happiness / bliss. Accordingly, the “overturn in the state of mind” sought by the Kantian himself implies “the highest act of freedom”, which is inaccessible to him and beyond which the perspective of the world as law is replaced for the subject by the perspective of the Kingdom of the Spirit in which the “selfhood” of each moral agent is practically overcome.

Contradiction and Kant’s Formula of Universal Law

The 'Only Possible Argument' of Kant: A Critical Reconstruction

Affection of Law: Fichte on the Place and Boundaries of Pure Ethics of the Imperative

Kant’s Theory of Concept Formation and his Theory of Definitions

Personal Life and Class Struggle

Weyl's Quantifiers

Kant and Mendelssohn on the limits of the Enlightenment

Grice and Kant on Maxims and Categories

Kant's Cognitive Approach to the Concept of Freedom:On the Origin of Categories in Critique of Pure Reason

A Leibnizian Logic of Possible Laws

Between Old and New Teleology. Kant on Maupertuis’ Principle of Least Action

Kantian and Neo-Kantian First Principles for Physical and Metaphysical Cognition

Kant's Theory of Freedom and Right

Logical Given, Interactive Negotiation and Self-Denial of Self-Consciousness-Hegelian Pragmatism in Contemporary Analytic Philosophy and Its Critique

The Theoretical Path of Kant's Argument on Freedom and Its Practical Dilemma

The Concept of Burger in Kant'S Philosophy of Law

Avoiding Contradictions in the Paradoxes, the Halting Problem, and Diagonalization

Kant's Moral and Legal Philosophy

Rules of Explosion and Excluded Middle: Constructing a Unified Single-Succedent Gentzen-Style Framework for Classical, Paradefinite, Paraconsistent, and Paracomplete Logics

Kant’s Virtue Theory

From Kant's "the Hatred of Reason" to Hegel's "the Cunning of Reason"