Abstract:This paper investigates the optimal pricing and return policies of an online retailer selling a product with multiple versions to consumers facing valuation uncertainty. Consumers resolve their uncertainty through bracketing, a practice wherein they purchase multiple versions with the intention of keeping the best fit and returning the rest. By establishing a Stackelberg game between the retailer and consumers, we investigate two return policies: one offering full refunds with purchase limits, and the other offering partial refunds (Q or R) under exogenous and endogenous pricing (N or P), yielding four scenarios: NQ, PQ, NR, PR. Our study provides key insights into optimal return policies for retailers, demonstrating that stringent return policies may not necessarily be more profitable compared to lenient ones when dealing with consumer bracketing. In the case of exogenous pricing, retailers providing convenient returns are better off charging return fees, while those facing cumbersome returns should offer full refunds under certain conditions. When jointly leveraging pricing, retailers have the flexibility to choose between the full-refund and partial-refund policies. We obtain several interesting findings. First, as the mismatch probability increases, retailers tend to charge higher return fees in Scenario PR, while adjusting optimal decisions (i.e., refund under the partial-refund policy and purchase limit under the full-refund policy) non-monotonically in other scenarios. Second, consumers receive nonnegative expected utility in the exogenous pricing scenario, whereas zero in the endogenous pricing scenario. Third, when returns become sufficiently convenient, retailers adopting the partial-refund policy under endogenous pricing shift toward offering full refunds. In addition, when considering heterogeneous consumers, we discover that in some cases, retailers can benefit from consumer bracketing.

Return and refund policy for product and core service bundling in the dual-channel supply chain

Pricing Strategy in a Dual-channel Supply Chain with Return Policy

Customer returns model in a dual-channel supply chain

Return strategy and pricing in a dual-channel supply chain

Price and Service Competition of Dual-Channel Supply Chain with Consumer Returns

Return Strategies and Online Product Customization in a Dual-Channel Supply Chain

Pricing strategy with quality improvement in a dual collection channel closed-loop supply chain under return uncertainty

Pricing And Return Policies In A Mixed Retail And E-Tail Distribution Channel

Decision and Coordination in the Dual-Channel Supply Chain Considering the Risk-Averse and Customer Returns

How to Implement Return Policies in A Two-Echelon Supply Chain?

Optimal operational policies of a dual-channel supply chain considering return service

Return Policy Model of Supply Chain Management for Single-Period Products

Managing Consumer Bracketing Purchases: Optimal Return Policy Analysis

The impact of customer returns in a supply chain with a common retailer

Return Mode Selection and Pricing Strategy for a Dual-Channel Retailer

Coordination of a supply chain with consumer return under demand uncertainty

A profit maximization for a reverse logistics dual-channel supply chain with a return policy

On the Introduction of Return Window to Supply Chains with Online Channel.

Returns policy, in-store service, and contract strategies in the presence of customer returns

Pricing Decision Models of the Dual Channel Supply Chain with Service Level and Return