Abstract:Abstract Teachers’ belief systems about the inclusion of students with special needs may explain gaps between policy and practice. We investigated three inter-related aspects of teachers’ belief systems: teachers’ cognitive appraisals (e.g., attitudes), emotional appraisal (e.g., feelings), and self-efficacy (e.g., agency to teach inclusive classrooms). To date, research in this field has produced contradictory findings, resulting in a sparse understanding of why teachers differ in their belief systems about inclusive education, and how teachers’ training experiences contribute to their development of professional beliefs. We used meta-analysis to describe the level and range of teachers’ beliefs about inclusive education, and examine factors that contribute to variation in teachers’ beliefs, namely (1) the point in teachers’ career (pre-service versus in-service), (2) training in special versus regular education, and (3) the effects of specific programs and interventions. We reviewed 102 papers (2000–2020) resulting in 191 effect sizes based on research with 40,898 teachers in 40 countries. On average, teachers’ cognitive appraisals, emotional appraisals, and efficacy about inclusion were found to be in the mid-range of scales, indicating room for growth. Self-efficacy beliefs were higher for preservice ( M = 3.69) than for in-service teachers ( M = 3.13). Teachers with special education training held more positive views about inclusion than regular education teachers ( d = 0.41). Training and interventions related to improved cognitive appraisal ( d = 0.63), emotional appraisal ( d = 0.63), and self-efficacy toward inclusive practices ( d = 0.93). The training was particularly effective in encouraging reflection of beliefs and, eventually, facilitating belief change when teachers gained practical experience in inclusive classrooms. Six key findings direct the next steps.

Rural Secondary Educators' Perceptions of Their Efficacy in the Inclusive Classroom

Comparison of perceptions among rural versus nonrural secondary science teachers: A multistate survey

Teachers' Attitudes toward Inclusion: Survey Results from Elementary School Teachers in Three Southwestern Rural School Districts

The Relationship Between Efficacy and the Instructional Practices of Special Education Teachers and Consultants

Understanding Shared Responsibility Between Special and General Education Teachers in the Rural Classroom

The Unseen Digital Divide: Urban, Suburban, and Rural Teacher Use and Perceptions of Web-Based Classroom Technologies

A Survey of Rural Special Education Teachers’ Professional Development Experiences

DIFFERENTIATED LEARNING FOR STUDENTS WITH SPECIAL NEEDS IN INCLUSIVE SCHOOLS (Teacher's Perception of Students Learning Profile)

Teachers’ Beliefs About Inclusive Education and Insights on What Contributes to Those Beliefs: a Meta-analytical Study

Rural High School Teachers’ Perceptions of Teaching and Learning When Using an Integrated Mathematics Curriculum

Teacher perceptions of implementation practices to support secondary students in special education

Teachers' Perceptions of ELL Students: Do Their Attitudes Shape Their Instruction?

Culturally Responsive Teaching Efficacy Beliefs of In-Service Special Education Teachers

Level of Teachers' Training in Inclusive Education and Their Sense of Efficacy

Improving Access to General Education via Co-Teaching in Secondary Mathematics Classrooms: An Evaluation of Utah’s Professional Development Initiative

Contrasting Instructional Technology Adoption in K-12 Education to Promote Digital Equity

Rural education: learning to be rural teachers

Improving Schools through a Response to Intervention Approach: A Cross-Case Analysis of Three Rural Schools

Teacher self-efficacy and inclusive education practices: Rethinking teachers’ engagement with inclusive practices

Good Teachers / Bad Teachers: How Rural Adolescent Students’ Views of Teachers Impact on Their School Experiences