Abstract:A passing maneuver allows drivers to maintain their desired speed on two-lane highways. However, it entails a high risk of collision with vehicles travelling in the opposite direction. Investigating drivers' behavior while performing passing maneuvers could provide helpful information on the factors that influence this process. Driving simulators have become important tools for driving behavior research studies as they are safe, facilitate the controlled use of experimental variables, and generate detailed output data. It remains to be seen whether simulator results can be considered representative of real-life driving conditions. With respect to passing maneuvers, no study has made a comprehensive and direct comparison between drivers' passing behavior in the field and driver behavior observed in a simulated environment. In this validation study, a fixed-base interactive simulator was used to collect data from fifty-four participants (eighteen Iranians and thirty-six Italians) involved in several traffic scenarios on a two-lane rural highway segment (obtained by varying the speed of opposing vehicles, lead vehicles and headways in the opposite direction). A 3D model and its environmental characteristics were realized from the real segment which had previously been surveyed with drones to collect videos and derive data on real passing maneuvers. The results for the two-sided K-S test revealed no statistically significant difference in the accepted gap, effective accepted gap, perception reaction time, and time to collision variables between the field and the simulator at the 95 % confidence level. However, when conducting a one-sided K-S test, some statistical directional differences were found in the cases of the accepted gap and perception reaction time variables, which exhibited lower values in the field compared to the simulator again at the 95 % confidence level. Although the passing duration was statistically higher in the simulator than in the field, the shape of the two distributions was not statistically different. Analysis showed that differences in the passing duration are due to the lower passing vehicle speed and lower speed difference with the simulator than in the field, which are caused by truncating headways in the subject direction in the simulator. The cultural background of participants did not result in any discernible difference in passing behavior. The results would support a more extensive use of driving simulators in future passing behavior studies.

Train-driving simulator studies: Can novice drivers deliver the goods?

The effects of driver training on simulated driving performance

Transition to manual: Comparing simulator with on-road control transitions

Driving simulator scenarios and measures to faithfully evaluate risky driving behavior: A comparative study of different driver age groups

Principal Components Analysis of Driving Simulator Variables in Novice Drivers

Exploring driving characteristics of fit- and unfit-to-drive neurological patients: a driving simulator study

Beyond Basics: Can a Driving Simulator Reliably Reproduce Real Vehicle Dynamics?

Effects Of A Simulation-Based Training Intervention On Novice Drivers' Hazard Handling Performance

The bigger the better? Investigating the effects of driving simulator fidelity on driving behavior and perception

Virtual Reality Driving Simulation for Measuring Driver Behavior and Characteristics

Why are newly qualified motorists at high crash risk? Modelling driving behaviours across the first six months of driving

Is driving experience all that matters? Drivers' takeover performance in conditionally automated driving

Do Drivers Vary in Preferences for Automated Driving Styles Across Different Scenarios? Evidence from a Simulation Experiment.

Can Three-Dimensional Multiple Object Tracking Training Be Used to Improve Simulated Driving Performance? A Pilot Study in Young and Older Adults

Novice driver crashes: The relation between putative causal factors, countermeasures, real world implementations, and policy – A case study in simple, scalable solutions

Investigation into passing behavior at passing zones to validate and extend the use of driving simulators in two-lane roads safety analysis

Carryover Effects of Highly Automated Convoy Driving on Subsequent Manual Driving Performance

Do young novice drivers overestimate their driving skills more than experienced drivers? Different methods lead to different conclusions

Validating self-reported driving behaviours as determinants of real-world driving speeds

What Makes a Fantastic Passenger-Car Driver in Urban Contexts?

Performance measurement in railway remote driving implementations