Expanding the Interpretive Potential of Eye Tracking for the Rorschach: Replication and Extension of the Findings of Ales et al. (2020)

Barry Dauphin,Harold H. Greene,Mindee Juve,Mellisa Boyle,Ellen Day,Emily Bemis
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00223891.2024.2303433
2024-01-27
Journal of Personality Assessment
Abstract:The present study was undertaken to determine if the findings of Ales et al. ( Citation 2020 ) could be replicated and extended, especially in light of the replication crisis in psychology and the social sciences. Ales et al. ( Citation 2020 ) found that measures from the engagement and cognitive processing domain of the Rorschach performance assessment system (R-PAS) were associated with Eye Tracking variables that reflect cognitive engagement and effort. Notably, Complexity was associated with the number of fixations participants made while scanning the blots and Vg% was inversely associated with a participant's average fixation durations. The present study utilized a non-clinical sample of 60 adult participants. The basic findings of Ales et al. ( Citation 2020 ) were replicated. In addition, we found that Complexity and Vg% are associated with additional Eye Tracking variables not utilized in the original study. The current findings bolster and extend the interpretation of Ales et al. ( Citation 2020 ), indicating that higher levels of Complexity are also associated with scanning more regions of the blot overall, albeit at a slower rate. Similar effect size values were observed in the two different cultural contexts. Higher levels of Vg% are associated with measures indicating shallower and more superficial search strategies, consistent with the interpretation of Vg% as indicative of a vague, impressionistic, and unsophisticated cognitive style.
psychology, clinical, social
What problem does this paper attempt to address?