Abstract:Current climate change models predict an increase in temperature variability and extreme events such as heatwaves, and organisms need to cope with consequent changes to environmental variation. Non-genetic inheritance mechanisms can enable parental generations to prime their offspring's abilities to acclimate to environmental change-but they may also be deleterious. When parents are exposed to predictable environments, intergenerational plasticity can lead to better offspring trait performance in matching environments. Alternatively, parents exposed to variable or unpredictable environments may use plastic bet-hedging strategies to adjust the phenotypic variance among offspring. Here, we used a model species, the threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus), to test whether putatively adaptive intergenerational effects can occur in response to shifts in environmental variation as well as to shifts in environmental mean, and whether parents employ plastic bet-hedging strategies in response to increasing environmental variation. We used a full-factorial, split-clutch experiment with parents and offspring exposed to three temperature regimes: constant, natural variation, and increased variation. We show that within-generation exposure to increased temperature variation reduces growth of offspring, but having parents that were exposed to natural temperature variation during gametogenesis may offset some early-life negative growth effects. However, these mitigating intergenerational effects do not appear to persist later in life. We found no indication that stickleback mothers plastically altered offspring phenotypic variance (egg size or clutch size) in response to temperature variation. However, lower inter-individual variance of juvenile fish morphology in offspring of increased variation parents may imply the presence of conservative bet-hedging strategies in natural populations. Overall, in our experiment, parental exposure to temperature variation had limited effects on offspring fitness-related traits. Natural levels of environmental variation promoted a potentially adaptive intergenerational response in early life development, but under more challenging conditions associated with increased environmental variation, the effect was lost.

Heatwave‐Induced Paternal Effects Have Limited Adaptive Benefits in Offspring

Short-term heat waves have long-term consequences for parents and offspring in stickleback

Exploring impacts of marine heatwaves: paternal heat exposure diminishes fertilization success in the purple sea urchin (Strongylocentrotus purpuratus)

Heatwaves inflict reproductive but not survival costs to male insects

Intergenerational plasticity to cycling high temperature and hypoxia affects offspring stress responsiveness and tolerance in zebrafish

Experimental heatwaves negatively impact sperm quality in the zebra finch

Fertility loss under thermal stress: males have lower fertility limits but no evidence of sex differences in sensitivity

Early warming stress on rainbow trout juveniles impairs male reproduction but contrastingly elicits intergenerational thermotolerance

Sub-chronic elevation in ambient temperature drives alterations to the sperm epigenome and accelerates early embryonic development in mice

Fertility up in flames: Reduced fertility indices as a consequence of a simulated heatwave on small African mammals

Intergenerational effects of ocean temperature variation: Early life benefits are short-lived in threespine stickleback

Timing-specific parental effects of ocean warming in a coral reef fish

Fertility loss and recovery dynamics after repeated heat stress across life stages in male Drosophila melanogaster: patterns and processes

Matching maternal and paternal experiences underpin molecular thermal acclimation

Impacts of global warming on fertility of male fishes: evidence from meta-analysis of temperature effects on spermatozoa motility

Fish reproduction in a warming world: vulnerable points in hormone regulation from sex determination to spawning

Paternal environment effects are driven by female reproductive fluid but not sperm age in an external fertilizer

Heatwaves are detrimental to fertility in the viviparous tsetse fly

Zebrafish parental progeny investment in response to cycling thermal stress and hypoxia: deposition of heat shock proteins but not cortisol

Chronic and acute thermal stressors have non-additive effects on fertility

Life stage-specific effects of heat stress on spermatogenesis and oogenesis in Drosophila melanogaster