The Similarities & Differences of the Classical Tragedies in China & Western Countries——Comparison between Dou E Yuan and Hamlet

Mengtian Fei

Abstract:Taking Dou E Yuan and Hamlet for example,from their persistence to ethics,the same structure of their character developing and their different ideas about fate,this paper explore about the similarities and differences of these two characters and causes.

Philosophy,History

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Chinese and Western Tragedy in "Dou E Yuan" and "Hamlet"

Li Hai-lian

Abstract:The article makes comparison in " Dou E Yuan"and"Hamlet",it is discovered the differences of chinese and western tragedy in culture root are mainly manifested in the differences of culture background,appreciative psychology and sensibility expressive manner in chinese and western nations.On points of view of tragedy character and tragedy conflic,it is discovered the western tragedy spirit is full play,the individual self-determinational consciousness is strong,while Chinese ancient tragedy spirit emphasizes connotation,tragedy character runs short of self-determinational consciousness.The author thinks appreciation of chinese and western tragedy should pay attention to sensibility experience.

Philosophy,History
Similarities and Differences in Revenge Motifs Between Hamlet and the Orphan of Zhao

Wenjia Xiong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.37420/j.pir.2024.011

2024-02-26

Abstract:“The Orphan of Zhao” written by Ji Junxiang who was a playwright in China’s Yuan Dynasty and “Hamlet” by William Shakespeare are two very classic literary works in East and the West, both with the theme of “revenge”. This article found that the similarities in revenge motif of the two works can be divided into four aspects: central themes、plot presentation、social background innuendo、political conspiracy. In the differences in revenge motif, there are obvious differences in three aspects: narrative form、means of Revenge、character portrayal. In-depth research found that the main reason for these similarities and differences is differences in cultural backgrounds.Through this comparative endeavor, we aim not only to highlight the divergent approaches to revenge between Eastern and Western literary traditions but also to deepen our comprehension of the unique characteristics, connotations, and cultural backgrounds inherent in these works. Moreover, this analysis endeavors to serve as a guiding framework for discerning common patterns in the developmental trajectory of literature across diverse ethnic groups. In essence, this study aspires to illuminate the rich tapestry of human storytelling while fostering a more profound appreciation for the multifaceted interplay between culture, society, and creative expression.
A Tentative Analysis of Difference of Revenge Between Chinese and Western Classical Literature: In the Case of Hamlet and The Orphan of Zhao

Ailan Ding

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3968/8938

2016-10-26

Abstract:Revenge is a cultural phenomenon that almost prevails in the various nationality ethics. There are many tragic works with the theme of revenge in Chinese and Western literature. The tragedy of Shakespeare’s Hamlet and the drama of Ji Junxiang’s The Orphan of Zhao in the Yuan Dynasty are outstanding representatives of the classical Western and Chinese tragedies with common theme of revenge. Although Shakespeare’s Hamlet and Ji Junxiang’s The Orphan of Zhao have the same revenge theme, people are more aware of big differences about the theme, tragedy aesthetics and cultural backgrounds, which differentiate the periods of social development, cultural traditions, national aesthetic awareness, historical cultural backgrounds and other aspects. This paper will employ the Parallelism Methodology to compare these two tragedies from four aspects, including the tragic theme, tragic figure, tragic conflict, and tragic ending. The purposes of this paper are to help readers gain a deeper understanding of characteristics and significance of these two kinds of tragedies and to delve into the effect of cultural background of literary works to explore some common laws about development of all national literature.

History,Sociology,Philosophy
On Hamlet and the Orphan of the Zhao's

Ma Ji-bin

Abstract:This article is to dip into the study of two famous tragedies,Hamlet written by William Shakespeare and the Orphan of the Zhao's by Ji Junxiang who was a playwright in China's Yuan Dynasty,The article contrasts the cultural backgrounds,plots and the heroes in both plays,and tries to explore their similarities and differences.

History
Comparison of Tragic Characters of Dou E and Anna Christie Female's the Other Status in Patriarchal Society

Chen Ke-pei

Abstract:Dou E described by Guan Hanqing and Anna in Eugene O'Nill's Anna Christie present the social and female problems in Chinese and western culture in different ages,but they have some amazing similarities.Both of them are victims in patriarchal society,in which women have no freedom but the obedience to the society and reality,and they are controlled by men,who think they are the master of the female.Although Dou E and Anna resist against the oppression from evildoers and society in their own way,they still totally fail.They don't realize the reason of their tragedy is that they are the Other in the society.In all the plays reflected the patriarchal society,no matter they are about China or the west,the ancient time or modern time,once the plays refer to the suffering of women,the tragic fate of female are usually coursed by their subsidiary status.

Sociology,History
A comparative study of Chinese and Western tragedies——Take “The Orphan of Zhao” and “The Orphan of China” as examples

Keming Lin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.61173/ta8vmk72

2024-06-06

Abstract:The miscellaneous opera Orphan Zhao, written by the Chinese Yuan Dynasty opera singer Ji Junxiang, has undergone a long period of circulation and adaptation. The work contains the traditional Confucian moral spirit and the values of advising the good and punishing the bad influencing the French writer Voltaire to write Orphans of China, which promoted the exchange of Chinese and Western cultures and the spread of the Chinese culture to the rest of the world. These two classic literary works reflect the similarities and differences between Chinese and Western cultures behind them. This paper uses the comparative research method to study these two works, based on cross-cultural theory, combining the texts of the two works, analysing the cultural differences from collectivism and individualism, the change of antagonists, dissecting the causes of the cultural differences, and analysing the cultural similarities from the comparison of Confucian morality and the values of good and evil.
On the differences between time concepts of taking revenge in Chinese and Western cultures——a comparative study of "Hamlet" and "Orphan of the Zhao's Family"

Chang Ying

Abstract:Though"Hamlet"and"Orphan of the Zhao Family"are both dramas on revenge,they have rendered totally different time concepts of taking revenge criticism on Hamlet's hesitation in taking revenge promptly and praise to the orphan of the Zhao s family for taking revenge twenty years afterwards.This paper has concluded that the differences between time concepts of taking revenge lie in the differences of different cultures.They are a reflection of the evolution of national emotions with the tide of thought,so- cial ethics and morals in the development process of society.They come from culture and are rooted in the mainstream thought of the time.

Sociology,Psychology
Exploring the Tragic Aesthetics in Hamlet and the Differences with Traditional Chinese Aesthetic Views

Yongcai Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/cx2jvd29

2024-04-03

International Journal of Education and Humanities

Abstract:Tragedy, as an important form of human art, transcends time and space with its profound emotions and noble spiritual content, becoming a carrier of cultural resonance around the world. In different cultural backgrounds, the aesthetics of tragedy presents a variety of styles. These differences are reflected not only in aesthetic orientation but also in expressive techniques and value pursuits. Hamlet, as a distinguished representative of Western tragedy, constructs a unique and magnificent tragic tableau through its deep psychological analysis, complex character development, and intense conflict. The complexity and contradiction of human nature are vividly displayed in this work. In contrast, traditional Chinese aesthetic concepts place more emphasis on harmony, balance, and inner beauty. This aesthetic orientation emphasizes the moderation of emotions and moral education, pursuing a restrained and implicit beauty. In traditional Chinese tragedies, characters are often more reserved and implicit, with more controlled and moderate emotional expression. Comparing the tragic aesthetics in Hamlet with traditional Chinese aesthetic views reveals significant differences in several aspects. This comparison helps us understand more deeply the art of tragedy under different cultural backgrounds, recognize the complexity and diversity of human nature, and profoundly appreciate the fragility and preciousness of life.
A Comparative Study of Female Images Between Traditional Drama and Modern DramaTaking Two for the Road and Dou E Yuan as Examples

Jialian Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54254/2753-7064/23/20230602

2023-12-20

Abstract:As a mature work of ancient Chinese tragedy, Dou E Yuan not only accuses the cruel reality of disregard for human life, but also has a great influence on later literature and drama. Up to now, it has also appeared as a classic in stage performances, teaching books, etc. Many dramas are deeply inspired by its artistry, theme and realism. The "red literary works" with the same goal as "two for the road" also need a strong political propaganda means to publicize revolutionary thoughts by means of this art form. From the perspective of female images in Dou E Yuan and Two for the Road, this paper comprehensively analyzes the embodiment of female personality characteristics, values and artistic techniques in the two dramas, and compares and investigates the characteristics, situations and changes of gender consciousness of female images in the two dramas.
Analyzing The Peony Pavilion and Romeo and Juliet from a Comparative Perspective of Chinese and Western Cultures

Yue Song

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/ijeh.v10i2.11583

2023-09-03

International Journal of Education and Humanities

Abstract:Literature, as an important part of culture in terms of ideology, is the most convenient material to study the characteristics of different cultures. This paper selects the masterpieces "Peony Pavilion" and "Romeo and Juliet" of the two great Chinese and Western dramatists, Tang Xianzu and Shakespeare, and compares and analyzes them in four aspects, namely, the background of the creation, plot design, main characters' image, and the ending of the love, so as to analyze the differences between the two works in the spirit of the Chinese and Western cultures, the way of thinking, the concepts of human beings, and the understanding of tragedy.
On the Essence and Uniqueness of Shakespeare’s Tragedy in Hamlet

Chaoqi Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.18282/l-e.v9i2.1425

2020-11-10

Abstract:Hamlet, written by Shakespeare, profoundly reveals the unbearable and dark feudal society in England. Although the works ended in tragedy, they did not find an entirely feasible way of social transformation. But Hamlett’s character, drama content and plot showed the advanced and unique spirit of humanism, revealing the huge gap between life and ideals. Therefore, the core content of this article is to study the characteristics of Hamlet, and then further explain its value to our society.
Different Approaches, Equally Satisfactory Results——Different Artistic Manifestation of Illusion and Ghosts in Mecbeth and Fa Tzu-du

Mei Xie

2003-01-01

Abstract:In both Shakespeare's Mecbeth and Chinese traditional drama Fa Tzu-du,supernatural and abnormal phenomenon such as illusion and ghosts were used to describe the dread and psychological sufferings of the two protagonists after their committing of the crimes, while these two approaches were manifested differently on the stage according to the western darama and the oriental drama. These two dramas are just like different tunes rendered with equal skill-they are different in approach but equally satisfactory in result. The charaterization of Mecbeth and Gong-sun Tzu-du and their nightmare after committing of the crimes warned people to resist the outer temptation and to control the evil inner desire and to lead a peaceful life.
On Differences and Similarities Between the Han and Tang Dynasties

牟发松

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-5579.2004.03.001

2004-01-01

Abstract:From the Qin and Han to the Sui and Tang dynasties the vast, unified empire system in the history of China went through its first complete circle from establishment, consolidation, collapse to reconstruction. In the circle there were so many similarities between the Han and the Tang that these two dynasties have usually been regarded together as the Han-Tang. Actually, there existed a lot of distinct differences between these two great dynasties apart from their inherent continuations. Through a study of those similarities and differences, we may discover further more characteristics and laws in the development of ancient history of China.
A Comparative Study of the Artistic Features of Chinese and Japanese Classical Dramas—— Taking Kunqu The Palace of Eternal Life and Noh Yang Guifei as examples

Luyang Ruan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2991/ichess-19.2019.10

2019-01-01

Abstract:Kunqu and Noh belong to oriental classical drama and possess the performance and characteristic feature, called “drama poem” and lyricism is their essential feature. As typical representative of classical drama in their country, Kunqu and Noh have different artistic characteristic involved in the arts intimately. So a comparative study on the similarities...
Tang Xianzu and Philip Sidney: A Comparative Study of Chinese and English Drama Theories

Huimin Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/25723618.2021.1943607

2021-01-02

Abstract:There is a vast difference between theatrical traditions of China and England as the two countries are geographically apart. Tang Xianzu (汤显祖 1550–1616) and Philip Sidney (1554–1586) lived at opposite ends of Eurasia and they had no idea of the other’s existence, let alone the other’s thoughts. Yet, by close attention to Tang Xianzu’s and Philip Sidney’s drama theories, I have identified striking similarities in terms of their focus on depth of thoughts and true feelings in artistic creation, their opinions and/or practices towards tragicomedy, and their views on the social functions of theater. Despite operating within diverse contexts – Tang in late Ming dynasty China and Sidney in Elizabethan England – commensurabilities of their drama theories further mark the departure for ruminations on perennial questions of human cognition and emotion process.
Comparison of the Artistic Traits between the Folk Songs of "Mo Shang Sang" and "Mu Lan Ci"

Huang Ji-bing

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-342X.2007.01.017

2007-01-01

Abstract:"Mo Shang Sang" and "Mu Lan Ci" are two magnificent folk songs in Yue Fu(official conservatory in the Han Dynasty),handed down from generation to generation and popular as ever.This article explains the artistic appeal of the two classics that reach the same goal by different routes in different aspects of their theme,character image,structure and language,and in this way it carries forward the artistic value in our traditional authorship as shown in the classical literature.
Comparison of Similarities and Differences of Chinese and Western Heroism from the Perspective of Image of Guan Yu and Achilles

Wei YANG,Jing YANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-8178.2015.03.010

2015-01-01

Abstract:As an eternal topic for human, the definition of hero has different meanings for different eras, na-tions, cultures and individuals. Unique heroes are shaped under the diverse culture background in their ages. And heroism is the root of the process of history, development of society and homization. It is also a symbol for certain culture and influences the development of human society in some sense. The image of heroes in Chinese and west-ern works shows a few differences because of cultural diversities, but similarities can be find from their own history and culture as well. Guan Yu and Achilles, as two famous heroes in history who stand for their own culture, pro-vide a good angel for us to explore differences and similarities between Chinese and western heroism.
A comparative study on ancient view of life and death in China and western countries and the performances in literary works

Chen Ke-pei

Abstract:Based on different traditional cultures,the view of life and death between ancient Chinese and westerners presents distinctive connotations.Confucianism and Taoism play an important role in ancient Chinese culture,so their interpretations on the view of life and death are representative in China.Confucianism,focusing on practicing "Three Builts",lays emphasis on realistic life in order to achieve immortality,while Taoism pays more attention to heavenly law,which is a view of natural way.On the contrary,the view on life and death in ancient western culture,starting from the perspective of "termination"(i.e.death),advocates the idea of "soul immortality".Chinese and western literary works show different situations under the influence of different views of life and death.

Sociology,Philosophy,History
Research into Comparison Between Chinese and Western Legality Literatures

HAN Chun-meng,SUN Yi-ping

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-344X.2005.06.003

2005-01-01

Abstract:In terms of the themes of " admonish kindhearted and penalize evil" and of "pursue equality in the whole society",the Chinese and the western legality literatures have the concordant humanism spirits.Nevertheless,because they were planted in different soil of society culture and affected by different legality spirits and culture traditions,There are many differences between them in the fields of ideal placement,artistic character and displayed manifestation.The deep research into the similarity and difference of such two types legality literature will promote the comparison and exchange between them.
A Comparison Between Li Yu's and John Dryden's Theories on Dramatic Languages

ZHU Yuan,LI Yuan-zheng

2009-01-01

Abstract:This paper conducts a comparative analysis of Li Yu's and John Dryden's representative critical comments on the languages employed in western drama and Chinese classical opera.It is focused on the three aspects of the languages in terms of its popularity and clarity,liveliness,and innovation.It illustrates how they evaluate each of the linguistic features in drama according to their own national linguistic features and aesthetic criteria.In addition,they advocate and implement their own linguistic criteria in drama,which has much affinity and some discrepancy.

The Similarities & Differences of the Classical Tragedies in China & Western Countries——Comparison between Dou E Yuan and Hamlet

Chinese and Western Tragedy in "Dou E Yuan" and "Hamlet"

Similarities and Differences in Revenge Motifs Between Hamlet and the Orphan of Zhao

A Tentative Analysis of Difference of Revenge Between Chinese and Western Classical Literature: In the Case of Hamlet and The Orphan of Zhao

On Hamlet and the Orphan of the Zhao's

Comparison of Tragic Characters of Dou E and Anna Christie Female's the Other Status in Patriarchal Society

A comparative study of Chinese and Western tragedies——Take “The Orphan of Zhao” and “The Orphan of China” as examples

On the differences between time concepts of taking revenge in Chinese and Western cultures——a comparative study of "Hamlet" and "Orphan of the Zhao's Family"

Exploring the Tragic Aesthetics in Hamlet and the Differences with Traditional Chinese Aesthetic Views

A Comparative Study of Female Images Between Traditional Drama and Modern DramaTaking Two for the Road and Dou E Yuan as Examples

Analyzing The Peony Pavilion and Romeo and Juliet from a Comparative Perspective of Chinese and Western Cultures

On the Essence and Uniqueness of Shakespeare’s Tragedy in Hamlet

Different Approaches, Equally Satisfactory Results——Different Artistic Manifestation of Illusion and Ghosts in Mecbeth and Fa Tzu-du

On Differences and Similarities Between the Han and Tang Dynasties

A Comparative Study of the Artistic Features of Chinese and Japanese Classical Dramas—— Taking Kunqu The Palace of Eternal Life and Noh Yang Guifei as examples

Tang Xianzu and Philip Sidney: A Comparative Study of Chinese and English Drama Theories

Comparison of the Artistic Traits between the Folk Songs of "Mo Shang Sang" and "Mu Lan Ci"

Comparison of Similarities and Differences of Chinese and Western Heroism from the Perspective of Image of Guan Yu and Achilles

A comparative study on ancient view of life and death in China and western countries and the performances in literary works

Research into Comparison Between Chinese and Western Legality Literatures

A Comparison Between Li Yu's and John Dryden's Theories on Dramatic Languages