The impact of sense of belonging on health: Canadian evidence

Ian Allan,Mehdi Ammi,F. Antoine Dedewanou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00036846.2024.2364075

IF: 1.916

2024-06-09

Applied Economics

Abstract:Sense of belonging to the community is presented as a fundamental human need, with existing evidence of its correlation with health. The relationship between belongingness and health is nevertheless endogenous as better health may foster belongingness in the community. We empirically examine the causal effect of belongingness on health using data from Canada, taking advantage of the multicultural nature of the Canadian society. We use data from the Canadian Community Health Survey from 2009 to 2014 augmented with other survey and administrative data. We address the endogeneity problem with instrumental variables, and construct instruments as the difference between the individual's and the neighbourhood's ethnocultural and homeownership characteristics. To account for the nonlinearity of the belongingness and health variables, we estimate our instrumental variables models by two-stage residual inclusion and a Bayesian estimation procedure. Our findings indicate that higher belongingness improves health, both for subjective measures like self-assessed health and objective measures like chronic conditions. While all age groups are positively affected, the effects are stronger for older adults, as well as for women. Health behaviours and healthcare utilization are potential mechanisms by which belongingness appears to affect health, in particular reduced smoking, and better access to a regular provider of care.

economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main issue this paper attempts to address is the exploration of the impact of a sense of belonging on health, and to test this impact through empirical data from Canadian society. Specifically, the authors focus on how community belonging (i.e., an individual's sense of identification with their community) affects personal health status, including subjective health assessments (such as self-assessed health status) and objective health indicators (such as chronic disease conditions). Additionally, the paper explores the differences in this impact across different age groups and genders, as well as possible mechanisms of action, such as health behaviors and medical utilization.

To overcome potential endogeneity issues between belonging and health (i.e., better health status may also promote community belonging), the authors employed an instrumental variable approach, constructing instrumental variables based on the differences in ethnic culture and homeownership rates between individuals and their residential areas. Through this method, they were able to more accurately estimate the causal effect of belonging on health. The study found that a higher sense of community belonging does indeed improve health status, particularly for older adults and women, where the effect is more pronounced. Reduced smoking and better access to regular medical services are among the main mechanisms through which belonging affects health.