Hybrid versus Conventional Colorectal Endoscopic Submucosal Dissection: A Multi-Center Randomized Controlled Trial (SHORT-ESD)

Dennis Yang,Muhammad K. Hasan,Salmaan Jawaid,Gurdeep Singh,Yasi Xiao,Mai Khalaf,Yutaka Tomizawa,Neil S. Sharma,Peter V. Draganov,Mohamed O. Othman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.14309/ajg.0000000000002897
2024-06-25
The American Journal of Gastroenterology
Abstract:Background: Hybrid endoscopic submucosal dissection (H-ESD) which utilizes ESD knife along with snare-based resection, has been developed to overcome the technical complexity of conventional ESD (C-ESD). This study aimed to compare the therapeutic outcomes of H-ESD vs. C-ESD for non-pedunculated colorectal lesions ≥20 mm in size. Methods: We conducted a multicenter randomized controlled trial to compare H-ESD and C-ESD (Short-ESD trial). Patients with colorectal lesions between 20-50 mm in size were randomly assigned (1:1) to H-ESD or C-ESD. Primary outcome was procedure time/speed. Secondary outcomes were en-bloc and complete (R0) resection rates and adverse event rates. Results: A total of 89 patients (median age 63 years; 49.3% women) with median polyp size 30 mm underwent H-ESD (n=40) and C-ESD (n=49). The mean procedure time of H-ESD was significantly shorter than that of C-ESD (41.1±16.3 vs. 54.3±28.2 minutes; p=0.007). The en-bloc and R0 resection rates trended lower in the H-ESD vs C-ESD groups (77.5% vs. 87.8%; p=0.26 and 72.5% vs. 79.6%; p=0.46) without reaching statistical significance. Adverse event rate was similar between H-ESD and C-ESD (10% vs 8.2%; p=1.00). Conclusion: Both H-ESD and C-ESD were safe and effective for resection of large colorectal lesions. H-ESD was associated with a shorter procedure time. H-ESD may represent a viable alternative to C-ESD, with the main advantage being easy applicability of a snare-based technique for colorectal lesions. Future studies are needed to further define the most suitable lesions for H-ESD, as to optimize efficiency and safety without compromising resection outcomes. ClinicaTrials.gov NCT NCT05347446.
gastroenterology & hepatology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?