Evaluation of indicators of acute emotional states in dogs

Hannah E. Flint,Jennifer E. Weller,Nia Parry-Howells,Zack W. Ellerby,Stephanie L. McKay,Tammie King

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-56859-9

IF: 4.6

2024-03-18

Scientific Reports

Abstract:A complete assessment of animal welfare requires not just an understanding of negative emotional states, such as fear and anxiety, but also of positive states, such as calmness and happiness. However, few studies have identified accurate and reliable indicators of positive emotional states in dogs. This study aimed to identify parameters that may serve as indicators of short-term emotional states in dogs. Using a cross-over design, 60 dogs living at a research facility were exposed to six different 10-min scenarios expected to elicit responses varying in emotional valence and arousal. A range of behavioural and physiological parameters were collected and their relationship to anticipated emotional valence and arousal was analysed using linear and logistic mixed models. Cortisol, adrenocorticotropic hormone, heart rate variability, panting, whining, and body shake all demonstrated significant differences based on arousal levels, but only within negative valence scenarios. Scores from a qualitative behavioural assessment (QBA) were associated with both emotional valence and arousal and were considered the best indicator of positive valence. Activity, ear temperature, and sitting were associated with positive high arousal, although this may have been influenced by differing levels of movement induced during these scenarios. Meanwhile, heart rate, secretory immunoglobulin A, standing and lying all showed similar changes associated with arousal for both positive and negative valence scenarios. This study provides a critical first step towards identifying evidence-based indicators of short-term emotional states in dogs, while highlighting considerations that should be made when employing these parameters, including the influence of coder bias, food provision, exercise, and external temperature. Overall, it is recommended future dog emotion and welfare research use a combination of parameters including indicators of both emotional valence and arousal.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to solve the problem of how to accurately assess dogs' short - term emotional states. Specifically, the research focuses on identifying physiological and behavioral parameters that can serve as reliable indicators of dogs in different emotional valence and arousal states. Most previous studies have focused on evaluating and reducing negative emotions (such as fear and anxiety), while there are fewer studies on the evaluation or promotion of positive emotions (such as happiness and relaxation). Therefore, the goal of this study is to fill this gap, identify effective indicators that can be used to evaluate dogs' positive emotions through experimental design, and explore the performance of these indicators in different emotional states. The study adopted a cross - over design, in which 60 dogs living in the research facilities experienced six different 10 - minute scenarios that were expected to trigger different levels of emotional valence and arousal responses. The researchers collected a series of behavioral and physiological parameters and analyzed the relationships between these parameters and the expected emotional valence and arousal using linear and logistic mixed models. The main findings include: - Parameters such as cortisol, adrenocorticotropic hormone, heart rate variability, panting, whining, and body shaking showed significant differences based on arousal levels in negative - valence scenarios. - Qualitative behavior assessment (QBA) scores were related to both emotional valence and arousal and were considered the best indicator of positive valence. - Parameters such as activity, ear temperature, and sitting were related to high positive arousal, but may be affected by different levels of movement in these scenarios. - Parameters such as heart rate, secretory immunoglobulin A, standing, and lying down had similar changes related to arousal in positive - and negative - valence scenarios. In addition, the study also explored the impact of providing food on these parameters, because the provision of food may interfere with the relationships between certain parameters and the dogs' emotional states. Overall, the study suggests that future research on dogs' emotions and welfare should use a combination of multiple parameters, including indicators of emotional valence and arousal, to more comprehensively assess the dogs' emotional health.

Evaluation of indicators of acute emotional states in dogs

Assessing positive emotional states in dogs using heart rate and heart rate variability

Evaluating the accuracy of facial expressions as emotion indicators across contexts in dogs

Assessing the Relationship Between Emotional States of Dogs and Their Human Handlers, Using Simultaneous Behavioral and Cardiac Measures

Assessing the welfare of kennelled dogs-A review of animal-based measures

Owner perceptions of companion dog expressions of positive emotional states and the contexts in which they occur

Assessment of positive emotions in animals to improve their welfare

Dogs distinguish authentic human emotions without being empathic

Sensitivity to reward loss as an indicator of animal emotion and welfare

Environmental enrichments and data-driven welfare indicators for sheltered dogs using telemetric physiological measures and signal processing

Sensor-supported measurement of adaptability of dogs (Canis familiaris) to a shelter environment: Nocturnal activity and behavior

Human Empathy, Personality and Experience Affect the Emotion Ratings of Dog and Human Facial Expressions

Dog-assisted intervention significantly reduces anxiety in hospitalized patients with major depression

Effects of Olfactory and Auditory Enrichment on Heart Rate Variability in Shelter Dogs

Problem Behaviours and Relinquishment: Challenges Faced by Clinical Animal Behaviourists When Assessing Fear and Frustration

Do Emotional Cues Influence the Performance of Domestic Dogs in an Observational Learning Task?

Intra and interspecific audience effect on domestic dogs' behavioural displays and facial expressions

The Use of Triaxial Accelerometers and Machine Learning Algorithms for Behavioural Identification in Domestic Dogs (Canis familiaris): A Validation Study

The odour of an unfamiliar stressed or relaxed person affects dogs' responses to a cognitive bias test

Cognitive bias as an indicator of animal emotion and welfare: Emerging evidence and underlying mechanisms

Lateralized behavior and cardiac activity of dogs in response to human emotional vocalizations