Passive Enhancement of Retinol Skin Penetration by Jojoba Oil Measured Using the Skin Parallel Artificial Membrane Permeation Assay (Skin-PAMPA): A Pilot Study
James V Gruber,Nicole Terpak,Sebastien Massard,Amber Schwartz,Krzysztof Bojanowski
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/CCID.S391667
2023-02-02
Abstract:James V Gruber, 1 Nicole Terpak, 2 Sebastien Massard, 2 Amber Schwartz, 3 Krzysztof Bojanowski 4 1 Research, Vantage Specialties, Fairfield, NJ, USA; 2 Research, Vantage Specialties, Warren, NJ, USA; 3 Production, Vantage Specialties, Tucson, AZ, USA; 4 Research, Sunny Biodiscovery, Santa Paula, CA, USA Correspondence: James V Gruber, Email Introduction: Retinol is known to have positive benefits on the skin including enhancements in barrier function, increased epidermal thickness, reductions in fine lines and wrinkles and reductions in hyperpigmentation. Improved methods to enhance the penetration of retinol are desirable. Methods: A study was conducted to examine if addition of natural jojoba ( Simmondsia chinensis ) oil might help passively enhance the penetration of retinol through the skin's lipid barrier. The model used to examine the passive penetration of the retinol is the skin parallel artificial membrane permeation assay (Skin-PAMPA). In this study, three formulations were examined. The formulations included two control blends: a moisturizing emulsion without retinol and the same product containing 1.0% retinol without jojoba oil. The remaining formulation contained similar concentrations of retinol with 10% jojoba oil. The studies were conducted by applying the products to the Skin-PAMPA models at 37°C/5% CO 2 for 16 hours and then extraction of the acceptor reservoir with cyclohexane (ratio 1:5 acceptor fluid to cyclohexane). The resulting acceptor reservoir cyclohexane solutions were analyzed for retinol by High Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC). Results: The formulations without retinol showed no indications of retinol penetration by HPLC. The control formulation with 1.0% retinol demonstrated that retinol had permeated the membrane in the 16-hour timeframe with a measured Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 7 units. Analysis of the formulation containing 1.0% retinol and 10% jojoba oil indicated retinol had permeated with a AUC of 285 units, a nearly 40-fold increase in active retinol permeation. Discussion: The ability for jojoba oil to directly act to help skin permeation of a key skin care active like retinol has not been previously demonstrated. This potential for jojoba oil to enhance passive skin penetration of critical skin actives, like retinol, can help to improve the performance of skin care products employing active topical ingredients. Keywords: skin permeation, retinoids, HPLC, lipid barrier, Simmondsia chinensis oil Jojoba ( Simmondsia chinensis ) seed oil is unique among the many naturally occurring plant oils. Most typical seed oils present themselves as fatty acid triglycerides which are formed in the seeds in small, individually packaged droplets called lipid bodies or oleosomes. 1 The stored oil is used to help provide nutrition during germination of the seeds. Jojoba oil, however, is comprised of liquid waxes, not triglyceride oils but is typically referred to as an oil due to the liquid nature of the waxy esters. 2 The oil is typically isolated on commercial scales by cold pressing to produce virgin oil often followed by a second pressing to produce non-virgin grades. 3 Jojoba oil is also unique among vegetable oils because of its stability against oxidation, a trait not shared by most triglyceride oils. The jojoba plant is particularly interesting as it grows under quite arid conditions which means the plant grows abundantly without the need for large quantities of water. Jojoba oil has been popularly used for many years in skin and hair care applications and has been shown more recently to have skin benefits including wound healing, emollient, hydrating, anti-inflammatory, and anti-microbial benefits, among others. 4–7 The linear wax esters that comprise jojoba oil share a very profound similarity to wax esters known to exist in human sebum. 8 This compatibility with human sebaceous lipids is likely one reason jojoba oil has been so popularly used in topical skin preparations. In addition, the oil lends itself to various natural chemical modifications to provide fatty acids and fatty alcohols as well as the hydrogenated esters, acids and alcohols which tend to be higher melting solid waxes. 3 Jojoba waxes and the various derivatives have been recognized as safe for use in cosmetics by the Cosmetic Ingredient Review Board since 2008. 9 Within the pantheon of skin care actives that have been proven efficacious, retinoids form one of the most popular ingredients used among consumers. Retinoic acid is a very powerful exfoliant with demonstrated antiaging, antimicrobial, and other homeostatic effe -Abstract Truncated-
dermatology