Abstract:Contingent convertibles (CoCos) and bail-in debt for banks have been proposed as potential mechanisms to enhance financial stability. They function by converting to equity when a bank approaches insolvency. We develop a capital structure model to analyze the incentives created by these forms of contingent capital. Our formulation includes firm-specific and market-wide tail risk in the form of two types of jumps and leads to a tractable jump-diffusion model of the firm's income and asset value. The firm's liabilities include insured deposits and senior and subordinated debt, as well as convertible debt. Our model combines endogenous default, debt rollover, and jumps; these features are essential in examining how changes in capital structure to include CoCos or bail-in debt change incentives for equity holders. We derive closed-form expressions to value the firm and its liabilities, and we use these to investigate how CoCos affect debt overhang, asset substitution, the firm's ability to absorb losses, the sensitivity of equity holders to various types of risk, and how these properties interact with the firm's debt maturity profile, the tax treatment of CoCo coupons, and the pricing of deposit insurance. We examine the effects of varying the two main design features of CoCos, the conversion trigger and the conversion ratio, and we compare the effects of CoCos with the effects of reduced bankruptcy costs through orderly resolution. Across a wide set of considerations, we find that CoCos generally have positive incentive effects when the conversion trigger is not set too low. The need to roll over debt, the debt tax shield, and tail risk in the firm's income and asset value have particular impact on the effects of CoCos. We also identify a phenomenon of debt-induced collapse that occurs when a firm issues CoCos and then takes on excessive additional debt: the added debt burden can induce equity holders to raise their default barrier above the conversion trigger, effectively changing CoCos to junior straight debt; equity value experiences a sudden drop at the point at which this occurs. Finally, we calibrate the model to past data on the largest U.S. bank holding companies to see what impact CoCos might have had on the financial crisis. We use the calibration to gauge the increase in loss absorbing capacity and the reduction in debt overhang costs resulting from CoCos. We also time approximate conversion dates for high and low conversion triggers.

Market‐Triggered Contingent Capital with Incomplete Information

On the Design of Contingent Capital with A Market Trigger

Design of Contingent Capital with a Stock Price Trigger for Mandatory Conversion

Contingent Capital with Stock Price Triggers in Interbank Networks

Capital Regulation under Price Impacts and Dynamic Financial Contagion

Preliminary Version Information , Diversification , and Cost of Capital ∗ †

Partial Equilibria with Convex Capital Requirements: Existence, Uniqueness and Stability

A Dynamic Model of Risk-Shifting Incentives with Convertible Debt

Shareholder Risk-Taking Incentives in the Presence of Contingent Capital

Financial Entanglement: A Theory of Incomplete Integration, Leverage, Crashes, and Contagion

Partial Equilibrium and Market Completion

Dynamic equilibrium with insider information and general uninformed agent utility

Equilibrium Defaultable Corporate Debt and Investment

Stock Market Insider Trading in Continuous Time with Imperfect Dynamic Information

Bank Capital, Interbank Contagion, and Bailout Policy

Sophisticated banking contracts and fragility when withdrawal information is public

Contingent Market Discipline and Risk-taking Incentive of Banks

Corporate investment and financing under asymmetric information

Allocation of risk capital in a cost cooperative game induced by a modified Expected Shortfall

Capital Regulation with Non-Maturing Deposits

CoCos, Bail-In, and Tail Risk