Closing the accessibility gap to mental health treatment with a personalized self-referral chatbot

Johanna Habicht,Sruthi Viswanathan,Ben Carrington,Tobias U. Hauser,Ross Harper,Max Rollwage
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-023-02766-x
IF: 82.9
2024-02-06
Nature Medicine
Abstract:Inequality in treatment access is a pressing issue in most healthcare systems across many medical disciplines. In mental healthcare, reduced treatment access for minorities is ubiquitous but remedies are sparse. Here we demonstrate that digital tools can reduce the accessibility gap by addressing several key barriers. In a multisite observational study of 129,400 patients within England's NHS services, we evaluated the impact of a personalized artificial intelligence-enabled self-referral chatbot on patient referral volume and diversity in ethnicity, gender and sexual orientation. We found that services that used this digital solution identified substantially increased referrals (15% increase versus 6% increase in control services). Critically, this increase was particularly pronounced in minorities, such as nonbinary (179% increase) and ethnic minority individuals (29% increase). Using natural language processing to analyze qualitative feedback from 42,332 individuals, we found that the chatbot's human-free nature and the patients' self-realization of their need for treatment were potential drivers for the observed improvement in the diversity of access. This provides strong evidence that digital tools may help overcome the pervasive inequality in mental healthcare.
biochemistry & molecular biology,cell biology,medicine, research & experimental
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the inequality in access among groups with different socioeconomic backgrounds, races, genders, etc. in mental health treatment. Specifically, the paper explores whether the use of a personalized self - referral chatbot can increase the number of referrals for mental health services, and pays special attention to whether this technology can effectively increase the referral rates of minority groups (such as non - binary - gender individuals and ethnic minority individuals), thereby reducing the barriers these groups face when seeking mental health support. ### Summary of the core issues in the paper: 1. **Increase in the overall referral volume**: - The research aims to evaluate whether the personalized self - referral chatbot can significantly increase the number of referrals for mental health services. - The results show that the referral volume of the service using this chatbot increased by 15%, while that of the control group only increased by 6%. 2. **Increase in the referral volume of minority groups**: - Special attention is paid to whether the referral volume of non - binary - gender individuals and ethnic minority individuals has increased. - The research found that the referral volume of non - binary - gender individuals increased by 179%, while that of the control group decreased by 5%. - The referral volume of ethnic minority individuals increased by 29%, while that of the control group only increased by 10%. 3. **Underlying mechanisms**: - Through natural language processing, the feedback of 42,332 users was analyzed to explore how the chatbot affects users' experiences and behaviors. - It was found that minority groups are more likely to mention the "no - real - person" feature of the chatbot, which may reduce the sense of stigma and judgment when they seek help. 4. **Impact on the quality of treatment**: - The research also evaluated whether the increase in referral volume would have a negative impact on waiting time and the number of clinical evaluations. - The results indicate that the use of the personalized self - referral chatbot did not significantly increase the waiting time or reduce the number of clinical evaluations, thus ensuring the quality of the service. ### Formula summary: - **Chi - square test**: - Used to compare the referral volume differences between two groups: \[ \chi^2(1)=86.3, \quad P < 0.0001 \] - Used to compare the referral volume differences among different gender groups: \[ \text{OR} = 2.95, \quad 95\% \text{ CI}=(2.065, 4.206), \quad P < 0.001 \] - **ANOVA**: - Used to evaluate the changes in waiting time and the number of clinical evaluations: \[ F(1, 13)=0.60, \quad P = 0.442 \] \[ F(1, 13)=0.78, \quad P = 0.381 \] \[ F(1, 13)=1.42, \quad P = 0.239 \] Through these research results, the paper provides strong evidence that digital tools, especially personalized self - referral chatbots, can play an important role in reducing the inequality in access to mental health services.