Self-concept Clarity and Meaning in Life: A Daily Diary Study in a Collectivistic Culture

Sijia Chen,Xiaoru Li,Shengquan Ye
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10902-024-00775-2
IF: 4.087
2024-06-23
Journal of Happiness Studies
Abstract:Despite the theoretical significance of self-concept clarity in meaning in life in Western thinking, there has been limited empirical investigation in collectivistic cultures. Consequently, the mechanism and boundary conditions of this effect remain unknown in such cultural contexts. To address this gap, we employed a daily-diary method spanning a period of 10 days, which allowed us to examine both the between-person and within-person effects of self-concept clarity on meaning in life, as well as the mediating role of three precursors of meaning (i.e., coherence, purpose, and significance), and the moderating role of independent self-construal among 83 Chinese participants. Multilevel regressions analyses demonstrated that individuals with higher trait self-concept clarity perceived higher meaning in their daily lives ( b = 0.28, SE = 0.08, p = .001); and on days when individuals experienced higher daily self-concept clarity than typical, their sense of meaning on that day also tended to be higher ( b = 0.39, SE = 0.04, p < .001). Multilevel mediation models showed that at the between-person level, trait self-concept clarity predicted daily meaning through the mediation of significance only ( b = 0.15, SE = 0.05, p = .002), while at the within-person level, daily self-concept clarity predicted daily meaning through all three precursors (0.03 < b s < 0.13, p s < .05). The effect of both trait and daily self-concept clarity were stronger among those with a low (vs. high) independent self-construal. Finally, there was a positive lagged effect of daily self-concept clarity on daily meaning ( β = 0.12, SE = 0.05, p = .014). These findings highlight the importance of cultivating a clear self-concept for experiencing meaning in daily life, particularly for those with a low independent self-construal in a collectivistic culture.
social sciences, interdisciplinary,psychology, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the relationship between self-concept clarity and meaning in life, and conducts the study within a collectivist cultural context. Below is a summary of the key issues the paper attempts to address: ### Research Background and Objectives - **Theoretical Significance and Research Gap**: Although Western theories highly emphasize the importance of self-concept clarity for meaning in life, empirical research in collectivist cultures is relatively scarce. Therefore, the mechanisms and boundary conditions of this influence in these cultural contexts remain unclear. - **Research Objectives**: By conducting a 10-day diary study in the collectivist cultural context of China, the study aims to examine the impact of self-concept clarity on meaning in life at the individual level and at specific time points. It also investigates whether this impact is mediated by three antecedents of meaning in life (coherence, purpose, and significance) and explores the moderating role of independent self-construal. ### Research Content - **Participants and Methods**: 83 Chinese university students were recruited to participate in a 10-day diary study, where they recorded their experiences daily. - **Measurement Tools**: - Self-Concept Clarity: Measured using the Self-Concept Clarity Scale (SCCS). - Meaning in Life, Coherence, Purpose, and Significance: Assessed using multiple single-item evaluations. - Independent Self-Construal: Measured using the scale developed by Singelis. - **Analysis Methods**: Multilevel regression analysis was used to handle the nested structure of the diary data and to examine the effects at different levels. ### Main Findings - **Individual Difference Effects**: Individuals with higher trait self-concept clarity reported higher meaning in life. - **Specific Time Point Effects**: On certain days, when individuals experienced higher self-concept clarity than usual, they also felt a higher meaning in life on that day. - **Mediation Effects**: At the individual difference level, trait self-concept clarity predicted daily meaning in life by increasing the "significance" of life. At specific time points, self-concept clarity predicted daily meaning in life by enhancing coherence, purpose, and significance. - **Moderation Effects**: The level of independent self-construal moderated the relationship between self-concept clarity and meaning in life, with the effect being more pronounced for individuals with lower independent self-construal. ### Conclusion - This study highlights the importance of cultivating a clear self-concept in a collectivist cultural context, especially for individuals with lower independent self-construal, as it is particularly important for experiencing meaning in daily life.