The Juxtaposition of Our Future Electrification Solutions: A View into the Unsustainable Life Cycle of the Permanent Magnet Electrical Machine

Leigh Paterson,Jill Miscandlon,David Butler
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16072681
IF: 3.9
2024-03-26
Sustainability
Abstract:Electrification is increasing in prevalence due to the importance placed on it for achieving global net zero targets. This has led to the proliferation of electrical mobility, including the wide-scale production of passenger vehicles, personal mobility devices and recent announcements regarding electrically powered aircraft, as well as in energy production. Electrical machines provide a cleaner source of energy during operation in comparison to their traditional fossil-based alternatives. The uncertainty and lack of transparency hanging over these green credentials can be attributed to how these products are manufactured and then disposed of at the end of their life. For them to be a truly sustainable solution, improvements need to be made across their entire life cycle. With the projected increase in their numbers due to the advancement of electrification, this current life cycle is not sustainable, directly opposing the intention of these products. This paper will introduce the current demand and challenges. It will also present these motors broken down into their constituent parts and follow each through their typical lifecycle. This paper presents the typical current life cycle of permanent magnet electrical machines, demonstrating the environmental issues associated with the current linear life cycle, and proposing alternative practices, to ease the environmental burden.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of the unsustainability of Permanent Magnet Electric Motors (PMEMs) throughout their entire lifecycle. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Current Demand and Challenges**: With the development of global electrification, especially the proliferation of products such as electric vehicles, personal mobility devices, and electric aircraft, the demand for permanent magnet electric motors has significantly increased. However, these motors present numerous environmental issues during their manufacturing and disposal processes, leading to the unsustainability of their lifecycle. 2. **Material Supply Chain Issues**: The rare earth elements used in permanent magnet electric motors (such as neodymium, dysprosium, etc.) face supply chain instability. For example, the price of neodymium has fluctuated significantly over the past 10 years, causing global concerns about material shortages and production halts. 3. **Environmental Impact**: The current lifecycle of permanent magnet electric motors is primarily a linear process, from raw material extraction to manufacturing, usage, and finally disposal, with each stage bearing significant environmental burdens. For instance, resource consumption and pollution during raw material extraction, energy consumption and waste emissions during manufacturing, and recycling challenges during disposal. 4. **Lack of Sustainable Design**: Although permanent magnet electric motors are more environmentally friendly during operation compared to traditional fossil fuel equipment, their overall lifecycle sustainability is still insufficient. The lack of sustainable design and manufacturing methods means that these motors may not be effectively recycled when they are massively retired in the future, further exacerbating resource shortages and environmental pollution issues. The paper proposes improvement measures through a detailed analysis of the lifecycle of various components of permanent magnet electric motors, aiming to reduce their environmental burden and achieve true sustainable development. This includes optimization in all stages, from raw material selection, manufacturing processes, usage and maintenance, to final recycling and disposal.