Benedikt Leichtmann,Thomas Meneweger,Christine Busch,Bernhard Reiterer,Kathrin Meyer,Daniel Rammer,Roland Haring,Martina Mara
Abstract:This study employs an innovative mixed-reality game to investigate trust, self-efficacy, and collaboration willingness with a mobile robot in relation to information and mental models. Previous research has demonstrated the significant impact of introductory information on technology use and trust, which further evolves over the course of interactions. Expanding on this, we explore new facets of information content through comprehensive measurements in two empirical studies: In study 1, 68 participants watched one of two video tutorials (high or low information richness) before collaborating with a physical robot in a shared virtual 3D environment. Repeated measures served to investigate temporal dynamics. In study 2, 37 participants additionally engaged in qualitative interviews to better understand how their mental models changed with increasing robot experience. Both tutorials were found to influence user trust and self-efficacy over time, with no significant differences between the two variants. Users valued information on how to communicate with the robot, but still relied on trial-and-error approaches. We argue for a moderating effect of information content and richness and highlight the need for carefully designed tutorials to enhance human-robot interaction.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects:
1. **Changes in trust, self - efficacy and willingness to cooperate**: The research aims to explore how participants' trust in robots, self - efficacy and willingness to cooperate change over time during the mixed - reality collaborative game with robots. In particular, how these psychological variables are affected by different levels of information richness.
2. **The impact of information richness on the dynamic adjustment of mental models**: By comparing two tutorials with different levels of information richness (high - information - richness and low - information - richness), the research explores how the information content affects the formation of participants' mental models (such as expectations and understanding of robots) and their dynamic adjustment over time.
3. **Research design of mixed methods**: In order to understand the above problems more comprehensively, the research adopts a method that combines quantitative experiments and qualitative interviews. Quantitative experiments test the changes of psychological variables by controlling variables (information richness), while qualitative interviews provide an in - depth understanding of the adjustment process of participants' mental models.
### Research Background
With the progress of technology and the reduction of costs, mobile collaborative robots are becoming more and more popular in industrial work environments. However, workers have different social and task - related concerns about the application of new robots in the workplace, such as worrying about the change of the nature of work or that robots may disrupt the work process. Therefore, workers need a period of time to get familiar with robots, understand their working and communication methods, in order to establish an effective collaborative relationship.
### Research Objectives
1. **Explore the impact of information richness on psychological variables**: The research manipulates the amount of information obtained by participants through two different tutorials (high - information - richness and low - information - richness) to test how this information affects participants' trust in robots, self - efficacy and willingness to cooperate.
2. **Analyze the dynamic changes of psychological variables**: Through multiple measurements, the research explores how these psychological variables change over time during the interaction, especially when the information richness increases.
3. **Combine quantitative and qualitative methods**: Through the combination of quantitative experiments and qualitative interviews, the research aims to provide a more comprehensive understanding and reveal the formation and adjustment process of participants' mental models.
### Research Methods
1. **Quantitative experiment**:
- **Sample**: A total of 68 participants participated in the game, and the data of 61 participants were finally analyzed.
- **Design**: A between - groups design was adopted, divided into two groups. One group received a basic - information tutorial (low - information - richness), and the other group received a detailed - information tutorial (high - information - richness).
- **Measurement**: Multiple measurements were carried out at different time points (T1, T2, T3, T4) of the game, including psychological variables such as trust, willingness to cooperate and self - efficacy.
2. **Qualitative interview**:
- **Sample**: 37 participants received qualitative interviews after the game.
- **Content**: The interview content included participants' understanding of robots and communication methods, as well as the changes in their mental models during the interaction process.
### Conclusion
The research results show that tutorials with different levels of information richness have a significant impact on participants' trust, self - efficacy and willingness to cooperate. The high - information - richness tutorial helps participants better understand and use robots, thereby increasing their trust and willingness to cooperate. In addition, the research also found that as the interaction time increases, participants' mental models of robots gradually become more accurate and rich.
Through this research, the author hopes to provide theoretical support for designing more effective robot training tutorials, thereby promoting the smooth progress of human - robot collaboration.