Abstract:Background & aims: When listing for liver transplantation, one can transplant as soon as possible or introduce a test-of-time to better select patients, as the tumor's biological behavior is observed. Knowing the degree of harm caused by time itself is essential to advise patients and decide on the maximum duration of the test-of-time. Therefore, we investigated the causal effect of waiting time on post-transplant survival for patients with hepatocellular carcinoma. Methods: We analyzed the UNOS-OPTN dataset and exploited a natural experiment created by blood groups. Relations between variables and assumptions were described in a causal graph. Selection bias was addressed by inverse probability weighting. Confounding was avoided using instrumental variable analysis, with an additive hazards model in the second stage. The causal effect was evaluated by estimating the difference in 5-year overall survival if all patients waited 2 months instead of 12 months. Upper bounds of the test-of-time were evaluated for probable scenarios by means of simulation. Results: The F-statistic of the first stage was 86.3. The effect of waiting 12 months vs. 2 months corresponded with a drop in overall survival rate of 5.07% (95% CI 0.277-9.69) and 8.33% (95% CI 0.47-15.60) at 5- and 10-years post-transplant, respectively. The median survival dropped by 3.41 years from 16.21 years (95% CI 15.98-16.60) for those waiting 2 months to 12.80 years (95% CI 10.72-15.90) for those waiting 12 months. Conclusions: From a patient's perspective, the choice between ablate-and-wait vs. immediate transplantation is in favor of immediate transplantation. From a policy perspective, the extra waiting time can be used to increase the utility of scarce donor livers. However, the duration of the test-of-time is bounded, and it likely should not exceed 8 months. Impact and implications: When listing patients with liver cancer for transplantation, it is unclear whether a test-of-time or immediate transplantation offer better outcomes at the population level. In this study, we found that increased liver transplant waiting times are detrimental in patients with liver cancer. Furthermore, our simulation showed that a pre-operative observational period can be useful to ensure good donor liver allocation, but that its duration should not exceed 8 months.

Donor Hepatectomy and Implantation Time Are Associated With Early Complications After Liver Transplantation: A Single-center Retrospective Study

Short-term and long-term outcomes of liver transplantation using moderately and severely steatotic donor livers: A systematic review.

Impact of Donor Hepatectomy Time During Organ Procurement in Donation After Circulatory Death Liver Transplantation: The United Kingdom Experience

Impact of Donor Age on Liver Transplant Outcomes in Patients with Acute-on-Chronic Liver Failure: A Cohort Study.

“Time is tissue”—A minireview on the importance of donor nephrectomy, donor hepatectomy, and implantation times in kidney and liver transplantation

Clinical Analysis of Early Allograft Dysfunction in Patients Receiving Donation after Cardiac Death Liver Transplantation

Impact of Intra-Operative Cholangiography and Parenchymal Resection to Donor Liver Function in Living Donor Liver Transplantation

Impact of the donor hepatectomy time on short‐term outcomes in liver transplantation using donation after circulatory death: A review of the US national registry

Older liver grafts from donation after circulatory death are associated with impaired survival and higher incidence of biliary non-anastomotic stricture

Early Allograft Dysfunction after Liver Transplantation with Donation after Cardiac Death Donors

Impact of waiting time on post-transplant survival for recipients with hepatocellular carcinoma: A natural experiment randomized by blood group

Initial Poor Graft Dysfunction and Primary Graft Non-Function after Orthotopic Liver Transplantation

Systematic Assessment of Safety Threshold for Donor Age in Cadaveric Liver Transplantation

Multi-Factor Analysis of Initial Poor Graft Function after Orthotopic Liver Transplantation

Impact of different ischemia times on biliary stricture after living donor liver transplantation with biliary atresia

Characteristics Associated with Liver Graft Failure: The Concept of a Donor Risk Index

Donor Complications Following Living Donor Hepatectomy: 17-Year Experience of a Single Team in One Institution of Japan.

Early Outcomes of Implanting Larger-Sized Grafts in Deceased Donor Liver Transplantation.

Factors related to delayed graft function after laparoscopic live donor nephrectomy

Evaluation outcomes of donors in living donor liver transplantation: a single-center analysis of 132 donors

Donor Diabetes and Steatosis Affects Recipient Survival Following Liver Transplantation Based on Etiology of Liver Cirrhosis