Abstract:Abstract Background The growing understanding of the oppressive inequities that exist in postsecondary education has led to an increasing need for culturally relevant pedagogy. Researchers have found evidence that beliefs about the nature of knowledge predict pedagogical practices. Culturally relevant pedagogy supports students in ways that leverage students’ own cultures through three tenets: academic success, cultural competence, and sociopolitical consciousness. If STEM practitioners believe that their disciplines are culture-free, they may not enact culturally relevant pedagogy in their courses. We investigated how and in what forms 40 faculty from mathematics, physics, chemistry, and biology departments at Hispanic-Serving Institutions enacted culturally relevant pedagogy. We used the framework of practical rationality to understand how epistemological beliefs about the nature of their discipline combined with their institutional context impacted instructors’ decision to enact practices aligning with the three tenets of culturally relevant pedagogy. Results In total, 35 instructors reported using practices that aligned with the academic success tenet, nine instructors with the cultural competence tenet, and one instructor with the sociopolitical consciousness tenet. Instructors expressed and even lauded their disciplines’ separation from culture while simultaneously expressing instructional decisions that aligned with culturally relevant pedagogy. Though never asked directly, six instructors made statements reflecting a “culture-free” belief about knowledge in their discipline such as “To me, mathematics has no color.” Five of those instructors also described altering their teaching in ways that aligned with the academic success tenet. The framework of practical rationality helped explain how the instructors’ individual obligation (to the needs of individual students) and interpersonal obligation (to the social environment of the classroom) played a role in those decisions. Conclusions Instructors’ ability to express two contradictory views may indicate that professional development does not have to change an instructor’s epistemological beliefs about their discipline to convince them of the value of enacting culturally relevant pedagogy. We propose departmental changes that could enable instructors to decide to cultivate students’ cultural competence and sociopolitical consciousness. Our findings highlight the need for future research investigating the impacts of culturally relevant pedagogical content knowledge on students’ experiences.

How syllabi relate to outcomes in higher education: A study of syllabi learner-centeredness and grade inequities in STEM

What Do Students Perceive from the Syllabus? The Importance of Syllabi to Communicate Belonging and Promote Engagement

Identifying systemic inequity in higher education and opportunities for improvement

Active learning narrows achievement gaps for underrepresented students in undergraduate science, technology, engineering, and math

Society's educational debts in biology, chemistry, and physics across race, gender, and class

The Syllabus: A Commitment to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in Nursing Education

All In: Understanding and Motivating Stakeholders to Create an Equitable Culture of Student Success

Equilibrium Grading Policies With Implications for Female Interest in STEM Courses

Equity in practice: Assigning competence to shape STEM student participation

Gender representation and academic achievement among STEM‐interested students in college STEM courses

Enacting inclusive science: Culturally responsive higher education practices in science, technology, engineering, mathematics, and medicine (STEMM)

Inequity exemplified by underrepresented minority students receiving lower grades and having higher rates of attrition across STEM disciplines

The role of epistemological beliefs in STEM faculty’s decisions to use culturally relevant pedagogy at Hispanic-Serving Institutions

Success with EASE: Who benefits from a STEM learning community?

An Exploratory Mixed-Methods Analysis of Factors Contributing to Students' Perceptions of Inclusion in Introductory STEM Courses

Course Deficit Model and the CLASP curriculum: Examining equity and graduation rates at two institutions

Education for a Future in Crisis: Developing a Humanities-Informed STEM Curriculum

Gender Inequities Throughout STEM: Compared to Men, Women with Significantly Higher Grades Drop STEM Majors

A Novel Undergraduate Seminar Course Celebrating Scientific Contributions by Scientists from Historically Marginalized Communities

Effects of a first-year undergraduate engineering design course: survey study of implications for student self-efficacy and professional skills, with focus on gender/sex and race/ethnicity

Cultural competence or deficit-based view? A qualitative approach to understanding middle school students’ experience with culturally framed engineering