Detection of enteroviruses in urban sewage by next generation sequencing and its application in environmental surveillance

Zexin Tao,Peng Chen,Ning Cui,Xiaojuan Lin,Feng Ji,Yao Liu,Ping Xiong,Li Zhang,Qing Xu,Yanyan Song,Aiqiang Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.138818

2020-08-01

Abstract:<p>Environmental surveillance has been used successfully in monitoring enterovirus (EV) circulation; however cell culture method may introduce a selective bias in those EV strains that are recovered from the environment. In this study, urban sewage samples were collected monthly in Jinan, China in 2018 and concentrated via membrane adsorption/elution method. A P1 seminested RT-PCR (RT-snPCR) and NGS method was developed, by which amplicons of 4000 nucleotide in length covering the entire P1 region of EVs were obtained from sewage concentrates and were further analyzed by next generation sequencing (NGS). In addition, for each sewage concentrate, two other assays - cell culture and NGS based partial VP1 amplicon sequencing - were conducted in parallel and compared. The results showed that the P1 RT-snPCR and NGS method generated the most data, with 32 serotypes identified belonging to species EV-A (<em>n</em> = 11), EV-B (<em>n</em> = 14), and EV-C (<em>n</em> = 7). These serotypes covered all those detected from the methods of cell culture (<em>n</em> = 10) and partial VP1 amplicon sequencing (<em>n</em> = 16). EV serotypes from acute flaccid paralysis surveillance correlated with those from sewage. Phylogenetic analysis on coxsackievirus B5, a common pathogen of meningitis, revealed close genetic relationship between environmental and clinical sequences. These results demonstrate sewage contains different EVs related to a variety of diseases. Traditional cell culture method underestimates the existence of some serotypes. NGS based environmental surveillance provides data which are consistent with those from clinical diseases, greatly improves our understanding on the actual circulation in the population, and should be encouraged for public health surveillance.</p>

environmental sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to address the issue of detecting enteroviruses in urban sewage and explore its application in environmental monitoring. Specifically, the research team developed a sensitive semi-nested P1 RT-PCR method to detect various enteroviruses in sewage samples and used next-generation sequencing (NGS) technology to identify these viruses. The main objectives of the study are:

1. **Develop a new detection method**: By developing a new semi-nested RT-PCR method to improve the sensitivity of detecting enteroviruses in sewage.
2. **Identify multiple enterovirus serotypes**: Using NGS technology, 32 different enterovirus serotypes were identified from sewage samples, including multiple types such as EV-A, EV-B, and EV-C.
3. **Compare the effectiveness of different detection methods**: The newly developed method was compared with traditional cell culture methods and partial VP1 gene sequencing methods, and it was found that the new method could detect a greater variety of virus serotypes.
4. **Explore the correlation between sewage and clinical diseases**: Through gene sequence comparison, it was found that certain viruses in sewage (such as Coxsackievirus B5) have a close genetic relationship with viruses in clinical diseases (such as aseptic meningitis).

Overall, this study demonstrates the advantages of NGS technology in environmental monitoring, providing a more comprehensive distribution of enterovirus serotypes, which is beneficial for public health surveillance.