Abstract:Maritime transport faces new safety challenges in an increasingly complex traffic environment caused by large-scale and high-speed ships, particularly with the introduction of intelligent and autonomous ships. It is evident that Automatic Identification System (AIS) data-driven ship trajectory prediction can effectively aid in identifying abnormal ship behaviours and reducing maritime risks such as collision, stranding, and contact. Furthermore, trajectory prediction is widely recognised as one of the critical technologies for realising safe autonomous navigation. The prediction methods and their performance are the key factors for future safe and automatic shipping. Currently, ship trajectory prediction lacks the real performance measurement and analysis of different algorithms, including classical machine learning and emerging deep learning methods. This paper aims to systematically analyse the performance of ship trajectory prediction methods and pioneer experimental tests to reveal their advantages and disadvantages as well as fitness in different scenarios involving complicated systems. To do so, five machine learning methods (i.e., Kalman Filter (KF), Support Vector Progression (SVR), Back Propagation network (BP), Gaussian Process Regression (GPR), and Random Forest (RF)) and seven deep learning methods (i.e., Recurrent Neural Network (RNN), Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM), Gate Recurrent Unit (GRU), Bi-directional Long Short-Term Memory (Bi-LSTM), Sequence to Sequence (Seq2seq), Bi-directional Gate Recurrent Unit (Bi-GRU), and Transformer) are first extracted from the state-of-the-art literature review and then employed to implement the trajectory prediction and compare their prediction performance in the real world. Three AIS datasets are collected from the waters of representative traffic features, including a normal channel (i.e., the Chengshan Jiao Promontory), complex traffic (i.e., the Zhoushan Archipelago), and a port area (i.e., Caofeidian port). They are selected to test and analyse the performance of all twelve methods based on six evaluation indexes and explore the characteristics and effectiveness of the twelve trajectory prediction methods in detail. The experimental results provide a novel perspective, comparison, and benchmark for ship trajectory prediction research, which not only demonstrates the fitness of each method in different maritime traffic scenarios, but also makes significant contributions to maritime safety and autonomous shipping development.

Prediction of ship following behavior in ice-covered waters in the Northern Sea Route based on hybrid theory and data-driven approach

A Bayesian network risk model for predicting ship besetting in ice during convoy operations along the Northern Sea Route

A Multi-Task Network with Dynamic Segmentation for Sea Ice Classification in Arctic Shipping Route Optimization

A Multi Ship Following Model for Icebreaker Escort Operations in the Baltic Sea

A Multi-Ship Following Model for Icebreaker Convoy Operations in Ice-Covered Waters

Towards a Probabilistic Model for Predicting Ship Besetting in Ice in Arctic Waters

Path Planning for Ships Assisted by the Icebreaker in Ice-Covered Waters in the Northern Sea Route Based on Optimal Control

A coupled kinematics model for icebreaker escort operations in ice-covered waters

Multi-ship following operation in ice-covered waters with consideration of inter-ship communication

A machine learning-based method for prediction of ship performance in ice: Part I. ice resistance

Data-driven Ship Energy Efficiency Analysis and Optimization Model for Route Planning in Ice-Covered Arctic Waters

Autonomous Navigation in Ice-Covered Waters with Learned Predictions on Ship-Ice Interactions

A Combined Experimental and Numerical Approach to Predict Ship Resistance and Power Demand in Broken Ice

A Dynamic Bayesian Network Model for Ship Navigation Risk in the Arctic Northeast Passage

Safety Distance Modeling for Ship Escort Operations in Arctic Ice-Covered Waters

A Novel Data-Driven Prediction Framework for Ship Navigation Accidents in the Arctic Region

Stability and energy consumption analysis of arctic fleet: modeling and simulation based on future motion of multi-ship

AIS data-driven ship trajectory prediction modelling and analysis based on machine learning and deep learning methods

Hybrid Deep Learning Models for Ship Trajectory Prediction in Complex Scenarios Based on Ais Data

Analysis of inland waterway ship performance in ice: Operation Time Window

Online Prediction Of Ship Behavior With Automatic Identification System Sensor Data Using Bidirectional Long Short-Term Memory Recurrent Neural Network