Simultaneous determination and risk assessment of highly toxic pesticides in the market-sold vegetables and fruits in China: A 4-year investigational study
Hui Li,Qiaoying Chang,Ruobin Bai,Xuechong Lv,Tengliang Cao,Shigang Shen,Shuxuan Liang,Guofang Pang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2021.112428
IF: 7.129
2021-09-01
Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety
Abstract:<p>This study investigated the levels of highly toxic pesticides (HTPs) in 6554 vegetable and fruit samples from 31 regions of China, along with the associated risk of dietary exposure for the population between 2014 and 2017. 18 HTPs were detected in 325 (4.96%) samples, and the levels of HTPs in 103 (1.57%) samples were found to be higher than the maximum residue limits (MRLs) of China. The rate of detection of HTPs in six types of vegetables and fruits, in a decreasing order, was found to be as follows: eggplant (8.84%) >grape (5.58%) >tomato (5.43%) >cucumber (5.43%) >pear (3.12%) >apple (2.30%). The level of contamination of HTPs was found to be higher in vegetables compared with fruits. The vegetable and fruit samples with the highest percentages of HTPs exceeding MRLs were found in eggplants from Guangxi (20%) and grapes from Inner Mongolia (12.5%), respectively. Both, the average target hazard quotient (THQ) of a single highly toxic pesticide (HTP) and the average hazard index (HI) of the mixture of HTPs for adults and children from vegetables and fruits from the 31 regions were found to be less than one. Omethoate, carbofuran, ethoprophos, triazophos, and phorate were identified as the major contributors to the average HI for vegetables, and carbofuran, ethoprophos, omethoate, phorate, and phosphamidon were identified as the primary contributors to the average HI for fruits. The results of this study revealed that HTPs in vegetables and fruits did not cause any significant chronic risk of dietary exposure. The detection of HTPs exceeding MRLs in some of the samples implied that appropriate management guidelines for HTPs should be implemented to protect the health of the consumers.</p>
environmental sciences,toxicology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the residue levels of highly toxic pesticides (HTPs) in vegetables and fruits sold in the Chinese market and their long - term dietary exposure risks to human health. Specifically, the research aims to:
1. **Investigate the residue levels of highly toxic pesticides**: By analyzing 6,554 vegetable and fruit samples collected from 31 provinces, autonomous regions and municipalities directly under the Central Government in China between 2014 and 2017, determine the detection rates and residue amounts of highly toxic pesticides in them.
2. **Evaluate dietary exposure risks**: Calculate and evaluate the impact on human health through the consumption of these vegetables and fruits containing highly toxic pesticide residues, especially the individual and cumulative dietary exposure risks for adults and children.
### Main problems include:
- **Detection of highly toxic pesticides**: Which vegetables and fruits have highly toxic pesticides detected? What are the detection rates and over - standard rates of highly toxic pesticides in different types of vegetables and fruits?
- **Regional differences**: Are there significant differences in the detection rates and over - standard rates of highly toxic pesticides in vegetables and fruits in different regions?
- **Major contributors**: Which highly toxic pesticides are the main sources of risk?
- **Health risk assessment**: By calculating the target hazard quotient (THQ) and the hazard index (HI), evaluate the potential risks of highly toxic pesticides to human health.
### Formula summary:
1. **Estimated daily intake (EDI)**:
\[
\text{EDI}=\frac{C\times W}{Bw}
\]
where:
- \(C\) is the average concentration of highly toxic pesticides in all collected vegetables or fruits (ng/kg)
- \(W\) is the average daily intake of vegetables or fruits (kg/d)
- \(Bw\) is body weight (kg)
2. **Target hazard quotient (THQ)**:
\[
\text{THQ}=\frac{\text{EDI}}{\text{ADI}}
\]
where:
- \(\text{ADI}\) is the acceptable daily intake (mg/kg·bw/day)
3. **Hazard index (HI)**:
\[
\text{HI}=\sum_{i = 1}^{n}\text{THQ}_i
\]
### Conclusion:
The research results show that although the residue amounts of highly toxic pesticides in some samples exceed China's maximum residue limits (MRL), overall, the chronic health risks caused by consuming these vegetables and fruits are not significant. However, in some regions, such as eggplants in Guangxi and grapes in Inner Mongolia, the over - standard rates of highly toxic pesticides are relatively high, suggesting that pesticide management in these regions needs to be strengthened to protect consumers' health.