Comparative study on effect of pomegranate peel powder as natural preservative and chemical preservatives on quality and shelf life of muffins

Namrata Ankush Giri,Aditi Bhangale,Nilesh N. Gaikwad,N. Manjunatha,Pinky Raigond,R. A. Marathe
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-61085-4
IF: 4.6
2024-05-06
Scientific Reports
Abstract:This research aims to investigate the potential of utilizing pomegranate peel powder (PPP) as a natural preservative in muffin preparation. Pomegranate peel is a rich source of bioactive compounds, including phenolics, flavonoids, and tannins, which possess high antioxidant and antimicrobial properties. The In-Vitro antifungal activity of pomegranate peel powder (8% PPP), potassium sorbate (0.1% PS) and calcium propionate (0.5% CP) was assessed against Penicillium sp. and Aspergillus sp. using poison food technique. The PPP showed the anti-fungal activity by delaying the growth of microorganism on media plate similar to the PS and CP. The effect of utilization of PPP on quality characteristics of muffins were compared with the muffins with chemical preservatives (0.1% PS and 0.5% CP). The viscosity and specific gravity of batter significantly increased from 7.98 to 11.87 Pa s and 1.089–1.398 respectively on addition of 8% PPP. The optical microscopic structure of PPP added batter revealed the decrease in the number of air cells from 24 to 12 with radius range of 6.42–72.72 μm and area range of 511.03–15,383.17 μm 2 . The functional properties of flour with PPP had higher water absorption capacity, foaming stability, emulsification activity and emulsion stability than others. The addition of PPP significantly increase the weight (32.83 g), and decrease the height (31.3 mm), volume (61.43 cm 3 ), specific volume (1.67 cm 3 /g) and baking loss (10.19%). The 418.36% increase in fibre content, 14.46% and 18.46% decrease in carbohydrates and energy value was observed in muffin with 8% PPP as compared to control respectively. The total phenols was increased from 0.92 to 12.5 mg GAE/100 g, total tannin from 0.2 to 8.27 mg GAE/100 g, In-vitro antioxidant activity by DPPH from 6.97 to 29.34% and In-vitro antioxidant activity by FRAP from 0.497 to 2.934 mg AAE/100 g in muffins added with 8% PPP. The muffin with PPP was softer than control and muffin with 0.1% PS. The addition of PPP resulted to improve in muffin texture but taste slightly bitter. During the storage of muffins at room temperature (27–30 °C), the moisture content of muffin with PPP was reduced from 17.04 to 13.23% which was higher than the rest of the treatments. Similarly, the hardness of sample with PPP was higher than the sample with 0.5% CP, but lowers than control and sample with 0.1% PS throughout the storage period. The results suggest that pomegranate peel powder can be successfully used as a natural preservative in place of chemical preservatives in muffins, to extend the shelf life. This study provides the opportunity to use PPP as functional ingredient and natural preservative in different bakery products.
multidisciplinary sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the application effect of pomegranate peel powder (PPP) as a natural preservative in muffin - making and compare it with the effects of chemical preservatives (such as potassium sorbate and calcium propionate). Specifically, the research aims to evaluate the influence of PPP on the quality characteristics of muffins (such as texture, color, nutritional components, etc.), as well as its potential in prolonging the shelf life of muffins. Through this research, the author hopes to provide a healthy, safe and functional natural preservative alternative to meet consumers' demand for healthier foods. ### Research Background - **Characteristics of Muffins**: Muffins are a wheat - based baked product with a soft texture and rich sweetness, and are loved by people of all ages. However, due to their high moisture content, muffins are prone to spoilage and have a short shelf life. - **Traditional Anticorrosion Measures**: Chemically, preservatives (such as calcium propionate and potassium sorbate) are usually used commercially to prolong the shelf life of muffins, but these chemical preservatives may have a negative impact on human health, such as toxicity, allergic reactions or the risk of long - term excessive intake. - **Demand for Natural Preservatives**: Currently, the food processing industry is looking for safer and healthier natural preservatives to meet consumers' demand for healthy foods. ### Research Purposes - **Evaluating the Antibacterial Activity of PPP**: Evaluate the inhibitory effect of PPP on molds (such as Penicillium and Aspergillus) through in vitro experiments. - **Comparing the Effects of PPP and Chemical Preservatives**: Study the influence of PPP on the quality characteristics of muffins (such as viscosity, specific gravity, color, texture, etc.) and compare it with muffins added with chemical preservatives. - **Evaluating the Influence of PPP on the Shelf Life of Muffins**: Evaluate the effect of PPP on prolonging the shelf life of muffins through storage experiments. ### Main Findings - **Antibacterial Activity of PPP**: The inhibitory effect of PPP on Penicillium and Aspergillus is significant, which is equivalent to or better than that of chemical preservatives. - **Influence of PPP on Muffin Quality**: - **Viscosity and Specific Gravity**: The viscosity and specific gravity of muffin batter with 8% PPP added increase significantly. - **Color**: The redness and yellowness values of muffin batter with PPP added increase significantly, while the brightness value decreases. - **Texture**: The muffins with PPP added are softer than the control group, but the taste is slightly bitter. - **Nutritional Components**: The fiber content of muffins with PPP added increases significantly, while the carbohydrate and energy values decrease. - **Antioxidant Activity**: The total phenol, tannin content and in vitro antioxidant activity of muffins with PPP added increase significantly. - **Shelf Life**: During storage at room temperature, the moisture content of muffins with PPP added decreases less, and the hardness is higher, but overall it is still better than other treatment groups. ### Conclusion The research results show that pomegranate peel powder can be successfully used as a natural preservative in muffins, which can not only prolong the shelf life of muffins, but also improve their nutritional value and functionality. This provides new opportunities for using PPP in different baked products.