Abstract:Abstract. In order to aid feature selection in thunderstorm nowcasting, we present an analysis of the utility of various sources of data for machine-learning-based nowcasting of hazards related to thunderstorms. We considered ground-based radar data, satellite-based imagery and lightning observations, forecast data from numerical weather prediction (NWP) and the topography from a digital elevation model (DEM), ending up with 106 different predictive variables. We evaluated machine-learning models to nowcast radar reflectivity (representing precipitation), lightning occurrence, and the 45 dBZ radar echo top height that can be used as an indicator of hail, producing predictions for lead times up to 60 min. The study was carried out in an area in the northeast United States, where observations from the Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite 16 are available and can be used as a proxy for the upcoming Meteosat Third Generation capabilities in Europe. The benefits of the data sources were evaluated using two complementary approaches: using feature importance reported by the machine learning model based on gradient boosted trees, and by repeating the analysis using all possible combinations of the data sources. The two approaches sometimes yielded seemingly contradictory results, as the feature importance reported by the gradient boosting algorithm sometimes disregards certain features that are still useful in the absence of more powerful predictors, while at times it overstates the importance of other features. We found that the radar data is overall the most important predictor, the satellite imagery is beneficial for all of the studied predictands, and the lightning data is very useful for nowcasting lightning but of limited use for the other hazards. The benefits of the NWP data are more limited over the nowcast period, and we did not find evidence that the nowcast benefits from the DEM data.

A physics-based ensemble machine-learning approach to identifying a relationship between lightning indices and binary lightning hazard

Identifying Lightning Processes in ERA5 Soundings with Deep Learning

Lightning Nowcasting with Aerosol-Informed Machine Learning and Satellite-Enriched Dataset

Forecasting of Local Lightning Using Spatial–Channel-Enhanced Recurrent Convolutional Neural Network

Supervised Learning-Based Prediction of Lightning Probability in the Warm Season

Lightning Location and Peak Current Estimation From Lightning-Induced Voltages on Transmission Lines With a Machine Learning Approach

Lightning risk assessment of offshore wind farms by semi-supervised learning

Thunderstorm nowcasting with deep learning: a multi-hazard data fusion model

Attention-Based Dual-Source Spatiotemporal Neural Network for Lightning Forecast

Using Machine Learning to Calibrate Storm-Scale Probabilistic Guidance of Severe Weather Hazards in the Warn-on-Forecast System

Critical comparison of potential machine learning methods for lightning thermal damage assessment of composite laminates

The Error is the Feature: how to Forecast Lightning using a Model Prediction Error

Inferring Thunderstorm Occurrence from Vertical Profiles of Convection-Permitting Simulations: Physical Insights from a Physical Deep Learning Model

Monitoring Lightning Location Based on Deep Learning Combined with Multisource Spatial Data

A machine-learning approach to thunderstorm forecasting through post-processing of simulation data

Nowcasting thunderstorm hazards using machine learning: the impact of data sources on performance

Modeling cloud-to-ground lightning probability in Alaskan tundra through the integration of Weather Research and Forecast (WRF) model and machine learning method

Lightning flash rate nowcasting based on polarimetric radar data and machine learning

Machine Learning-Based Lightning Localization Algorithm Using Lightning-Induced Voltages on Transmission Lines

Towards an Interpretable CNN Model for the Classification of Lightning Produced VLF/LF Signals

A Lightning Classification Method Based on Convolutional Encoding Features