The Potential for Rapid Evolution under Anthropogenic Climate Change

Renee A. Catullo,John Llewelyn,Ben L. Phillips,Craig C. Moritz
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2019.08.028
IF: 9.2
2019-10-01
Current Biology
Abstract:Understanding how natural populations will respond to rapid anthropogenic climate change is one of the greatest challenges for ecologists and evolutionary biologists. Much research has focussed on whether physiological traits can evolve quickly enough under rapidly increasing temperatures. While the simple Breeder's equation helps to understand how extreme temperatures and genetic variation might drive within-population evolution under climate change, it does not consider two key areas: how different forms of phenotypic plasticity interact and variation among populations. Plasticity can modify the exposure to climatic extremes and the strength of selection from those extremes, while differences among populations provide adaptive diversity not apparent within them. Here, we focus on terrestrial vertebrates and, with a case study on a tropical lizard, demonstrate the complex interplay between spatial, genetic and plastic contributions to variation in climate-relevant physiological traits. We identify several problems that need to be better understood: which traits are under selection in a changing climate; the different forms of plasticity relevant to population persistence and rapid evolution; plastic <em>versus</em> genetic contributions to geographic variation in climate-associated traits and whether plasticity can be harnessed to promote persistence of species. Given ongoing uncertainties around whether natural populations can evolve rapidly enough to persist, we advocate the use of field trials aimed at increasing rates of adaptation, especially in systems known to be strongly impacted by human-driven changes in climate.<figcaption><span class="figure__title__text">Different forms of plasticity.</span><a class="accordion__control" href="#"><span>Show full caption</span></a>Illustration of how environmental variation and different forms of plasticity would affect a tolerance trait (solid lines) affected by temperature (dashed lines) in a population with annual seasonal variation and non-overlapping generations. (Upper left) Gradual and reversible acclimation. (Upper right) Transient heat shock responses. (Bottom left) Effect of developmental plasticity, where generation time is less than one year to illustrate effect of development under different thermal conditions. The boxes in the bottom left panel show development time (grey) and the period as mature individuals (white). In the bottom right panel where individuals behaviourally moderate activity to prevent heat stress, letters refer to periods of high activity (A), restricted activity (R), and inactivity (I).<ul class="rlist--inline separator download-links"><li><a href="//els-jbs-prod-cdn.literatumonline.com/cms/attachment/462cf405-fd0e-42df-af6a-92c4a4d81637/fx1.jpg">View Large Image </a></li><li class="download-links__figureViewer"><a class="figure__open__ctrl" href="#">Figure Viewer</a></li><li><a class="download-links__download-Hi-res" href="//els-jbs-prod-cdn.literatumonline.com/cms/attachment/afb89296-1467-4b3d-a20d-6284692f4010/fx1_lrg.jpg">Download Hi-res image </a></li><li class="hidden-xs"><a class="download-links__download-This" href="/action/downloadFigures?pii=S0960-9822(19)31077-2&amp;id=fx1.jpg">Download (PPT)</a></li></ul></figcaption><figcaption><span class="figure__title__text">Trait plasticity and adaptive variation.</span><a class="accordion__control" href="#"><span>Show full caption</span></a>(Left) Critical thermal minimum (CT<sub>min</sub>), (Middle) Critical thermal maximum (CT<sub>max</sub>) and (Right) desiccation rate for southern rainforest sunskinks. Results from two populations are shown in a reflected order. Sunskinks were tested immediately after collection from the field (field), after 6 months, acclimation to the lab (F0lab), and in the lab-reared F1 generation (F1). Plot points represent mean ± SE of (1) groups of sunskinks collected at different times/seasons for the field-collected generation (field and F0lab) or (2) all the F1s from the same population. Colour indicates the season the parental generation was collected. The dashed horizontal line shows mean of the F1 population means.<ul class="rlist--inline separator download-links"><li><a href="//els-jbs-prod-cdn.literatumonline.com/cms/attachment/19908f74-99f9-409f-8c5a-f668ef921d70/fx2.jpg">View Large Image </a></li><li class="download-links__figureViewer"><a class="figure__open__ctrl" href="#">Figure Viewer</a></li><li><a class="download-links__download-Hi-res" href="//els-jbs-prod-cdn.literatumonline.com/cms/attachment/2bee8242-98f6-4289-bfd0-5c330dc3eb3d/fx2_lrg.jpg">Download Hi-res image <p>-Abstract Truncated-</p>
cell biology,biochemistry & molecular biology,biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?