A Methodology for Vulnerability Assessment of Cultural Heritage in Extreme Climate Changes

Riccardo Cacciotti,Alessandro Sardella,Miloš Drdácký,Alessandra Bonazza

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13753-024-00564-8

IF: 4.5

2024-06-13

International Journal of Disaster Risk Science

Abstract:Vulnerability evaluation plays a key role in risk assessment and reduction and is essential for defining strategies for climate change adaptation and mitigation. In dealing with the safeguarding of cultural heritage at risk, we are still far from adopting and applying an agreed methodology for vulnerability assessment. With the aim to support practitioners, heritage managers, and policy and decision makers to undertake actions that address the protection of cultural heritage at risk, the methodology set up in the framework of the Interreg Central Europe STRENCH is illustrated and discussed here. Based on three major requirements (susceptibility, exposure, and resilience) and a continuous consultation with local stakeholders, the proposed methodology is applicable for evaluating the vulnerability of built heritage and cultural landscape exposed to hydrometeorological hazards, such as heavy rains, floods, and droughts. The results obtained through its validation on 15 case studies from seven Central European regions are shown to underline the strengths and limitations of the methodological approach. Iterative consultation with local stakeholders was fundamental for the definition of the criteria/subcriteria and related values for the assessment of the requirements. Application to further sites in other contexts would surely contribute to strengthening the reliability of the methodological approach.

geosciences, multidisciplinary,meteorology & atmospheric sciences,water resources

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to address the risk assessment and management issues faced by cultural heritage ecosystems under extreme climatic conditions. Specifically, it attempts to provide a proven methodology for evaluating and ranking the vulnerability of cultural heritage (including architectural heritage and natural landscapes) affected by specific hydrometeorological disasters such as floods, landslides, storms and fires. This methodology was developed within the framework of the Interreg Central Europe STRENCH project and applied in 15 case studies in seven different European regions.

The paper emphasizes the central role of vulnerability assessment in risk management and reduction, especially its importance in formulating adaptation and mitigation strategies for climate change. However, in the field of cultural heritage protection, there is currently no widely accepted vulnerability assessment methodology. Therefore, this study proposes a multi - criteria decision - analysis framework (MIVES) based on three main factors (sensitivity, exposure and resilience), and defines the evaluation criteria and their associated values through continuous consultation with local stakeholders.

Through the application of this methodology, researchers hope to support practitioners, heritage managers, and policy - and decision - makers to take action to address the challenges in cultural heritage protection. The paper also presents the results of validating this methodology through 15 case studies, highlighting its strengths and limitations, and points out that further application in other contexts will help enhance the reliability of the methodology.