Abstract:This paper proposes an integrated approach to indeterminacy and epistemic uncertainty in order to model an intelligent agentʼs decision making about the assertability of vague statements. Initially, valuation pairs are introduced as a model of truth-gaps for propositional logic sentences. These take the form of lower and upper truth-valuations representing absolutely true and not absolutely false respectively. In particular, we consider valuation pairs based on supervaluationist principles and also on Kleeneʼs three-valued logic. The relationship between Kleene valuation pairs and supervaluation pairs is then explored in some detail with particular reference to a natural ordering on semantic precision. In the second part of the paper we extend this approach by proposing bipolar belief pairs as an integrated model combining epistemic uncertainty and indeterminacy. These comprise of lower and upper belief measures on propositional sentences, defined by a probability distribution on a finite set of possible valuation pairs. The properties of these measures are investigated together with their relationship to different types of uncertainty measure. Finally, we apply bipolar belief measures in a preliminary decision theoretic study so as to begin to understand how the use of vague expressions can help to mitigate the risk associated with making forecasts or promises. This then has potential applications to natural language generation systems.

Compatibility of Quantitative and Qualitative Representations of Belief

Probability Measures Compatible with the Fuzzy Dempster-Shafer Belief Structure

Belief Function to Probability: A Tradeoff Between Easy Decision-Making and High Risk

A Modified Belief Entropy in Dempster-Shafer Framework

On Truth-Gaps, Bipolar Belief and the Assertability of Vague Propositions

Comparative Uncertainty, Belief Functions and Accepted Beliefs

Enrichment Of Qualitative Beliefs For Reasoning Under Uncertainty

A Savage-style Utility Theory for Belief Functions

Analyzing the Monotonicity of Belief Interval Based Uncertainty Measures in Belief Function Theory.

Probing the Quantitative-Qualitative Divide in Probabilistic Reasoning

General combination rules for qualitative and quantitative beliefs

Comparative Study of Contradiction Measures in the Theory of Belief Functions

Fusion of qualitative beliefs using DSmT

Comparison of Qualitative Belief Degrees Belonging to Different Sets and Its Application

Transferable Belief Model on Quantum Circuits

CD-BFT: Canonical Decomposition-Based Belief Functions Transformation in Possibility Theory.

Analyzing the combination of conflicting belief functions

Modeling Belief Propensity Degree: Measures of Evenness and Diversity of Belief Functions

How to quantify the coherence of a set of beliefs

An Interpretation of Belief Functions by means of a Probabilistic Multi-modal Logic

Quantum Belief Function