Abstract:Recently, a new interesting idea of origin of gravity has been developed by Verlinde. In this scheme of emergent gravity, where horizon entropy, microscopic de Sitter states and relevant contribution to gravity are involved, an entropy displacement resulting from matter behaves as a memory effect and can be exhibited at sub-Hubble scales, namely, the entropy displacement and its “elastic” response would lead to emergent gravity, which gives rise to an extra gravitational force. Then galactic dark matter effects may origin from such extra emergent gravity. We discuss some concepts in Verlinde’s theory of emergent gravity and point out some possible problems or issues, e.g., the gravitational potential caused by Verlinde’s emergent apparent dark matter may no longer be continuous in spatial distribution at ordinary matter boundary (such as a massive sphere surface). In order to avoid the unnatural discontinuity of the extra emergent gravity of Verlinde’s apparent dark matter, we suggest a modified dark-baryonic mass relation (a formula relating Verlinde’s apparent dark matter mass to ordinary baryonic matter mass) within this framework of emergent gravity. The modified mass relation is consistent with Verlinde’s result at relatively small scales (e.g., \(R<3h_{70}^{-1}\) Mpc). However, it seems that, compared with Verlinde’s relation, at large scales (e.g., gravitating systems with \(R>3h_{70}^{-1}\) Mpc), the modified dark-baryonic mass relation presented here might be in better agreement with the experimental curves of weak lensing analysis in the recent work of Brouwer et al. Galactic rotation curves are compared between Verlinde’s emergent gravity and McGaugh’s recent model of MOND (Modified Newtonian Dynamics established based on recent galaxy observations). It can be found that Verlinde rotational curves deviate far from those of McGaugh MOND model when the MOND effect (or emergent dark matter) dominates. Some applications of the modified dark-baryonic mass relation inspired by Verlinde’s emergent gravity will be addressed for galactic and solar scales. Potential possibilities to test this dark-baryonic mass relation as well as apparent dark matter effects, e.g., planetary perihelion precession at Solar System scale, will be considered. This may enable to place some constraints on the magnitudes of the MOND characteristic acceleration at the small solar scale.

Comment on "Inconsistencies in Verlinde's emergent gravity"

The Dark-Baryonic Matter Mass Relation for Observational Verification in Verlinde’s Emergent Gravity

Newton's gravitation-force's classical average proof of a Verlinde's conjecture

Emergent Gravity Paradigm: Recent Progress

Emergent modified gravity: Covariance regained

Is Gravity an Entropic Force?

Considerations on Gravity as an Entropic Force and Entangled States

A note on the novel 4D Einstein–Gauss–Bonnet gravity

Entropic Forces and Newton's Gravitation

Apparent dark matter as a non-local manifestation of emergent gravity

A Unified Approach to Geometric Modifications of Gravity

Reply to Sergiu I. Vacaru's "Critical remarks on Finsler modifications of gravity and cosmology by Zhe Chang and Xin Li"

Emergent Cosmology in 4D Einstein Gauss Bonnet Theory of Gravity

Comments on "A clarification on prevailing misconceptions in unimodular gravity"

The Other Way Around: From Alternative Gravity to Entropy

Inconsistencies in four-dimensional Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet gravity

Gravity and fluid dynamic correspondence on a null hypersurface: inconsistencies and advancement

Emergent Modified Gravity

Hidden symmetries for thermodynamics and emergence of relativity

Comment on "Problems with Mannheim's conformal gravity program"