Heroes and Homosexuals: Education and Empire in E. M. Forster
Quentin Bailey
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1215/0041462X-2002-4002
2002-01-23
Abstract:He had brought out the man in Alec, and now it was Alec's turn to bring out the hero in him.... They must live outside class, without relations or money; they must work and stick to each other till death. But England belonged to them. -- Forster, Maurice 208-09 In October 1912, the successful, 33-year-old novelist E. M. Forster sailed from England in search of material for an Indian novel. Conventional wisdom has it that he was suffering something of an artistic crisis at the time: the success of Howards End in 1910 had placed tremendous pressures on the young writer, and 1911 had been a "terrible year on the whole" (Furbank 204) .To recover his creative impulses, according to this narrative of discovery, Forster traveled to India, taking extensive notes and writing frequently to friends and family about his trip. On his return to England, he wrote the first draft of an openly homosexual novel, Maurice, in a matter of weeks. Eleven years later, after a second trip to the subcontinent and a devastating war, Forster finally wrote his much acclaimed Indian novel in January 1924. It was published in a matter of months. Maurice, by contrast, remained hidden from all but Forster's closest friends until his death in 1970. It was published a year later to mixed reviews. Cri tical reception of the two novels has followed a similar trajectory: A Passage to India is taught in both canonical and postcolonial classrooms; Maurice remains primarily the province of queer studies. Panoramic studies surveying Forster's oeuvre build a narrative to the apex that is A Passage to India, relegating Maurice to the section on "Minor Fiction & Short Stories." And yet, for all this difference in writing, publication, reception, and appropriation, the two novels are inextricably linked by the trips to In dia. This relationship, however, is hidden behind the fiction(s) of modernism. It is a textual relationship that cannot speak its name until the modernist aesthetics of alienation and exile begin to wane. But it is a relationship whose political power becomes apparent as we read backwards from A Passage to India to Maurice, examining the system of education in the imperial age that helped construct the possibilities for both these novels of unspeakable love. The textual space within which Maurice exists is revealed, in this reading, to be a result of the educational practices of a period that sought to align national interests with an upper-middle-class agenda. In its construction of the socially unspeakable, Maurice reveals the limits of representation that the Anglo-Saxon myth of Englishness, born of postmutiny imperialism, places on narrative modernist texts--lim its that also construct, in A Passage to India, the literally unspeakable (the "ou-bourn" of the caves). Finally, reading A Passage to India and Maurice together discloses the extent to which educational practice--which sought to control social and racial differences within a narrow conception of sexual identity--encouraged the development of an aesthetic we have come to know, broadly, as modernism. In this essay, then, I first account for A Passage to India's canonization by comparing it to Heart of Darkness, and then situate these novels within certain historical and educational trends of the period. Understanding cultural productions in light of both literary and educational texts, we can grasp what Ronald Schleifer calls modernism's "apocalyptic sense of the new" (Modernism 68) in its relation to a specific racial, social, and sexual hierarchy. In Maurice, the discursive intersection of literature and education--which takes the form of a collision between canonically sanctioned meanings (of origins and influences) and alternative historical figurations (of empires and identities)--discloses the material limits of modernist representation. Colonial texts, canonical acceptance Maurice was written in 1913, falling neatly between what are arguably the two major works of colonial fiction in English: Heart of Darkness and A Passage to India. …
History,Education