Abstract:The United Nations' Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) recognized Indigenous rights to self-determination. How these rights can be realized in territories governed by settler-states remains unclear. For fisheries, the need to understand processes that support Indigenous self-determination has gained urgency due to government commitments and investor interest in developing ocean and coastal resources, or Blue Economies, amid rapid climatic changes. Here, we explored Indigenous groups' fishery development experiences following two approaches to reconciling Indigenous fishing rights. In New Zealand, we examined Māori groups' experiences following the 1992 Treaty of Waitangi (Fisheries Claims) Settlement Act. The Settlement granted Māori iwi (tribes) rights to self-govern non-commercial harvests, restrict fishing pressure in state-approved customary fishing areas, and participate in state-run systems for commercial fisheries management. In Canada, we investigated Indigenous fishery development initiatives following the Supreme Court of Canada's 1999 ruling R. v. Marshall . Marshall reaffirmed Treaty-protected rights to harvest and trade fish, held by Mi'kmaq, Wolastoqey, and Peskotomuhkati Peoples, to support a "moderate livelihood." We document how, in both cases, Indigenous groups' self-determination remains constrained by actions from state regulatory and enforcement agencies that govern market access, other resource users' activities, and processes for collecting and sharing information about fish populations. Indigenous groups' experiences highlight that: 1) reallocations of harvest rights, on their own, are an insufficient means to redistribute access to benefits from fisheries; 2) the constraints Indigenous families have experienced in their attempts to develop small-scale fishing operations correspond to settler-state policies and cannot be addressed solely through changes to Indigenous leaders' management decisions; and 3) polycentricity in governance regimes can pose problems for Indigenous self-determination, when citizens with political authority resist efforts to support Indigenous fisheries. To address these challenges, we call for legal reforms that require settler-state governments to support Indigenous self-determination, to overcome the political risks politicians face when advocating for a non-majority group's interests.

Indigenous climate justice in Aotearoa New Zealand: the dangers of (mis)recognition within climate policymaking

Māori ways of speaking: Code-switching in parliamentary discourse, Māori and river identity, and the power of Kaitiakitanga for conservation

Land Use Policy Frameworks in Canada and Aotearoa New Zealand: Examining the Opportunities and Barriers of Indigenous-Led Conservation and Protected Areas

A 'te ao Māori' disaster risk reduction framework

Climate change impacts on Aotearoa New Zealand: a horizon scan approach

Behind the smoke and mirrors of the Treaty of Waitangi claims settlement process in New Zealand: no prospect for justice and reconciliation for Māori without constitutional transformation

How Indigenous communities in New Zealand are protecting their data

Culturally mediated perceptions of climate change risks in New Zealand

The Critical Juncture in Aotearoa New Zealand and The Collective Future: Policy Issues in Settler/Invader Colonial Zombiism Found in “Biculturalism”

Māori and the natural environment from an occupational justice perspective

The Treaty Claims Settlement Process in New Zealand and its Impact on Māori

Indigenous land-based practices for climate crisis adaptions

An Exemplar

Attitudes towards climate migrants in Aotearoa New Zealand: the roles of climate change beliefs and immigration attitudes

Courts as Decision-Makers on Sea Level Rise Adaptation Measures: Lessons from New Zealand

Te Tiriti o Waitangi compliance in regulated health practitioner competency documents in Aotearoa

Constitutional Law-making by International Law: The Indigenization of Free Trade Agreements

Looking backwards to move forwards: insights for climate change adaptation from historical Māori relocation due to natural hazards in Aotearoa New Zealand

Multilevel governance, climate (in)justice, and settler colonialism—evidence from First Nations disaster evacuations in so-called Canada

Problems Faced by Duty to Consult and the Protection of Aboriginal Peoples in Canada

Indigenous self-determination in fisheries governance: implications from New Zealand and Atlantic Canada