Abstract:The purpose of this study is to observe the impact of celebrity endorser authenticity and product congruence on brand experience, brand evaluations and celebrity evaluations. Celebrity authenticity is defined by the celebrity’s ability to demonstrate rarity and stability, or their ability to maintain unique characteristics and talents consistently across time and situation. Congruence is how well a celebrity endorser matches with the brand’s product or product category. Previous studies suggest that both of these constructs independently enhance brand evaluations, such as brand loyalty, positive word of mouth, and emotional connection. In this case, authenticity and congruence were observed together. To test whether authenticity and congruence jointly impacted brand experience, brand evaluations, and celebrity evaluations, an experiment was conducted. In order to ensure internal validity, known brands and known celebrities were not used. Instead, a vignette approach was utilized. I found that, overall, authentic and congruent endorsement independently produced the strongest brand experience and the strongest evaluations. Authenticity and congruence together did not produce a synergistic effect but independently, when a celebrity endorser was authentic versus not authentic, evaluations were better and when a celebrity was congruent versus incongruent, evaluations were better. Therefore, in conclusion, if brand managers are looking to enhance brand experience or brand evaluations through celebrity endorsement, it is best to hire a celebrity that is authentic and a celebrity that is aligned with the brand’s product or product category. Additionally, if looking to enhance the evaluations of their currently contracted celebrity endorsers, perceived authenticity significantly impacts these evaluations. An overarching insight this study demonstrates, however, is that in an age of excess use of technology and social media where information is more readily available, it is important for companies to look beyond just profession when determining the best endorsement candidate to hire.

A Call for Authenticity: Audience Responses to Social Media Influencer Endorsements in Strategic Communication

Authentic isn't always best: When inauthentic social media influencers induce positive consumer purchase intention through inspiration

Celebrity vs. Influencer endorsements in advertising: the role of identification, credibility, and Product-Endorser fit

Influencer Marketing and Authenticity in Content Creation

Authenticity in TikTok: How content creator popularity and brand size influence consumer engagement with sponsored user‐generated content

What drives digital engagement with sponsored videos? An investigation of video influencers' authenticity management strategies

Digital influencers in different cultural contexts: effects of authenticity and value perceptions

A Proposed Model of Self-Perceived Authenticity of Social Media Influencers

Influencer Endorsements: How Advertising Disclosure and Source Credibility Affect Consumer Purchase Intention on Social Media

The Effects of Celebrity Endorser Authenticity and Product Congruence on Brand Experience

Hope You’re Not Totally Commercial! Toward a Better Understanding of Advertising Recognition's Impact on Influencer Marketing Effectiveness

To be real or not to be real? The effect of genuine (vs. nongenuine) depictions of social media influencers on followers' well‐being and brand purchase intention

Social media advertising endorsement: the role of endorser type, message appeal and brand familiarity

Is authenticity key? Mobilization by social media influencers versus celebrities and young people's political participation

It Must Be Excellent If an Instagram Star Endorses It, Right? Inquiring About the Parasocial Interactions and Online Purchase Intention

Ethics of Authenticity: Social Media Influencers and the Production of Sponsored Content

Authenticity under threat: When social media influencers need to go beyond self-presentation

Influencer marketing: explaining the effects of influencer self-presentation strategies on brand responses through source credibility

Under the Influence: Social Media Influencers’ Impact on Response to Corporate Reputation Advertising

Social Media Influencers’ Traits and Purchase Intention: A Moderated Mediation Effect of Attitude Towards Brand Credibility and Brand Familiarity

Consumer attitudes and purchase intentions towards internet celebrity self-brands: an integrated view of congruence, brand authenticity and internet celebrity involvement