Abstract:Models based on ecological processes (process‐explicit models) are often used to predict ecosystem responses to environmental changes or management scenarios. However, models are imperfect and need to be validated, ideally by testing their assumptions and outputs against independent empirical data sets. Examples of validation of process‐explicit models are rare. Recently, stochastic population models have been developed to predict the likely responses (over 10–120 years) of a riverine fish (golden perch, Macquaria ambigua) to flow management in the Murray–Darling Basin (MDB) in eastern Australia, one of the world's most regulated river basins. Declines in golden perch (and other species) are a direct consequence of altered hydrology, and managers require information to predict how fish will respond to possible future hydrological conditions to guide substantial investments in flow management. Here, we use two independent field data sets to validate our population model. We compared model predictions to observed trends to ask: (1) How do predicted population sizes and growth rates compare with observed data? (2) Does the correlation between predicted and observed population sizes and growth rates vary among populations? (3) Does the correlation between predicted and observed population sizes and growth rates vary across observed hydrological conditions? (4) How do modeled and observed fish movement rates compare? We found reasonable correlations between fish population sizes and growth rates as predicted by the model and observed in independent data sets for several populations (Aim 1), but the strength of these correlations varied among populations (Aim 2) and hydrological conditions (Aim 3). Predicted and observed fish movement rates were strongly correlated (Aim 4). Population models are frequently used in conservation decision‐making but are rarely validated. We demonstrate that: (1) validation can identify model strengths and weaknesses; (2) observed data sets often have inherent limitations that can preclude robust validations; (3) validation is likely to be more common if appropriate observed data sets are available; and (4) validation should consider the purpose of modeling. Wider consideration of these messages would contribute to more critical examinations of models, so they can be most appropriately used in conservation decision‐making.

Sustaining high-value salmonid populations in regulated rivers: insights from individual-based modelling of brown trout and Atlantic salmon

Hydrological and thermal effects of hydropeaking on early life stages of salmonids: A modelling approach for implementing mitigation strategies

Thermal alterations of hydro power: Modelling the effect on growth of juvenile salmonids

Is my model fit for purpose? Validating a population model for predicting freshwater fish responses to flow management

Individual-based modelling of fish population dynamics in the river downstream under flow regulation

Hydropower-induced selection of behavioural traits in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar)

Individual based modeling of fish migration in a 2-D river system: model description and case study

Contrasting effects of climate change in continental vs. oceanic environments on population persistence and microevolution of Atlantic salmon

Forecasting hydrologic controls on juvenile anadromous fish out-migration with process-based modeling and machine learning

Modelling the future hydroclimatology of the lower Fraser River and its impacts on the spawning migration survival of sockeye salmon

Spawning migration behaviour of sea trout (Salmo trutta L.) in a boreal river system: effects of flow conditions and obstacles on migratory activity

Challenges in downstream dam passage and the effect of dam removal on Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) smolt migrations

Mediterranean brown trout catch-and-release recreational fisheries might not be sustainable under concurrent climate warming and hydrological change

Environmental flow scenarios for a regulated river system: projecting catchment‐wide ecosystem benefits and consequences for hydroelectric production

Reducing Carryover Effects on the Migration and Spawning Success of Sockeye Salmon through a Management Experiment of Dam Flows

Environmental flows in a future climate: Balancing hydropower production and ecosystem rehabilitation in the Ume River system, Sweden

The complex interaction of ecology and hydrology in a small catchment: a salmon's perspective

Assessing contributions of cold-water refuges to reproductive migration corridor conditions for adult salmon and steelhead trout in the Columbia River, USA

Integrating two‐dimensional water temperature simulations into a fish habitat model to improve hydro‐ and thermopeaking impact assessment

Swimming behaviour of Atlantic salmon kelts migrating past a hydropower plant dam: Effects of hydraulics and dam operations

Ecological Flow Assessment: Balancing Trout and Grayling Habitat Ecology and Hydroelectric Production