Abstract:Charge-transfer (CT) is an important binding force in the formation of intermolecular complexes, and there have been a variety of theoretical models proposed to quantify this effect. These approaches, which typically rely on a definition of a “CT-free” state based on a partition of the system, sometimes yield significantly different results for a given intermolecular complex. Two widely used definitions of the “CT-free” state, the absolutely localized molecular orbitals (ALMO) method (where only on-fragment orbital mixings are permitted) and the constrained density functional theory (CDFT) approach (where fragment electron populations are fixed), are carefully examined in this work. Natural bond orbital (NBO) and the regularized symmetry-adapted perturbation theory (SAPT) are also briefly considered. Results for the ALMO and CDFT definitions of CT are compared on a broad range of model systems, including hydrogen-bonding systems, borane complexes, metal–carbonyl complexes, and complexes formed by water and metal cations. For most of these systems, CDFT yields a much smaller equilibrium CT energy compared to that given by the ALMO-based definition. This is mainly because the CDFT population constraint does not fully inhibit CT, which means that the CDFT “CT-free” state is in fact CT-contaminated. Examples of this contamination include (i) matching forward and backward donation (e.g., formic acid dimer) and (ii) unidirectional CT without changing fragment populations. The magnitude of the latter effect is quantified in systems such as the water dimer by employing a 3-space density constraint in addition to the orbital constraint. Furthermore, by means of the adiabatic EDA, it is shown that several observable effects of CT, such as the “pyramidalization” of the planar BH3 molecule upon the complexation with Lewis bases, already appear on the “CT-free” CDFT surface. These results reveal the essential distinctions between the ALMO and CDFT definitions of CT and suggest that the former is more consistent with accepted understanding of the role of CT in intermolecular binding.

A non-perturbative pairwise-additive analysis of charge transfer contributions to intermolecular interaction energies

Defining the Contributions of Permanent Electrostatics, Pauli Repulsion, and Dispersion in Density Functional Theory Calculations of Intermolecular Interaction Energies.

Pairwise Additivity and Three-Body Contributions for Density Functional Theory-Based Protein-Ligand Interaction Energies

From Intermolecular Interaction Energies and Observable Shifts to Component Contributions and Back Again: A Tale of Variational Energy Decomposition Analysis.

Charge transfer interaction revisited by a Fermi-Dirac derived approach

Toward transferable interatomic van der Waals interactions without electrons: The role of multipole electrostatics and many-body dispersion

Noncovalent Interactions in Density Functional Theory: All the Charge Density We Do Not See

On the Computational Characterization of Charge-Transfer Effects in Noncovalently Bound Molecular Complexes

Simultaneous identification of strong and weak interactions with Pauli energy, Pauli potential, Pauli force, and Pauli charge

Calculation of Intermolecular Interaction Energies by Direct Numerical Integration over Electron Densities. I. Electrostatic and Polarization Energies in Molecular Crystals

On the characterization of charge-transfer effects in non-covalently bound molecular complexes.

A general tight-binding based energy decomposition analysis scheme for intermolecular interactions in large molecules

Communication: Charge-population based dispersion interactions for molecules and materials

Self-consistent Coulomb interactions for machine learning interatomic potentials

Probing non-covalent interactions with a second generation energy decomposition analysis using absolutely localized molecular orbitals.

Force Decomposition Analysis: A Method to Decompose Intermolecular Forces into Physically Relevant Component Contributions

A DFT Approach to Non-Covalent Interactions via Monomer Polarization and Pauli Blockade

An automated Calculation Pipeline for Differential Pair Interaction Energies with Molecular Force Fields using the Tinker Molecular Modeling Package

ON THE EXACT EVALUATION OF INTERMOLECULAR ELECTROSTATIC INTERACTION ENERGY IN A MOLECULAR COORDINATE SYSTEM

Making Many-Body Interactions Nearly Pairwise Additive: The Polarized Many-Body Expansion Approach

Virial Relations in Density Embedding