Ethics and Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells [1]

S. Yamanaka

Abstract:The recent development of induced pluripotent stem cells [5] (iPSCs) and related technologies has caught the attention of scientists, activists, politicians, and ethicists alike. IPSCs gained immediate international attention for their apparent similarity to embryonic stem cells [6] after their successful creation in 2006 by Shinya Yamanaka [7] and in 2007 by James Thompson and others. Although iPSCs may appear to solve the controversy over the destruction of embryos in embryonic stem cell (ESC) research by involving only the genetic reprogramming [8] of somatic cells, further analysis of the new technique and its subsequent ethical issues could potentially lessen some ethical advantages iPSCs seemingly hold over ESCs. ESC research is laden with ethical concerns, particularly regarding the ideas of personhood , human dignity, and justice toward humankind that arise from dealing with human life in one of its earliest forms, the embryo. It is a controversial international issue, and many governing bodies have either banned the research altogether or placed restrictions on what may be done with embryos and ESCs. Additional ethical concerns surrounding such research include informed consent [10] , improper inducement, and health and safety risks for women donating eggs necessary for the creation of embryos via in-vitro fertilization [11] . Though these issues do not exhaust the list of ethical considerations of ESC research, they represent the chief topics occupying those interested in its ethical aspects. iPSCs have been touted as ethically uncomplicated alternatives to ESCs, so the ethics surrounding iPSCs are largely evaluated in comparison to those involving ESCs. If iPSCs turn out to be a useful alternative to ESC research, they will avoid the most significant concerns in feminist ethics [12] surrounding the issue. Because no eggs are needed for iPSCs, there is no unequal burden on women for supplying the necessary cells for the technology. The egg donation [13] process is often the most worrisome aspect of ESC research due to concerns for the women’s health during and after the invasive surgery;

Medicine,Philosophy