An Empirical Study of the Impact of Specialization , Workload and Product Personalization on Consumer Returns

S. Rajagopalan,Hailong Cui,Amy R. Ward
Abstract:Problem Definition: Are consumer product returns largely a function of retailers’ return policies or can manufacturers influence them through production characteristics and product attributes? How do operational levers under a manufacturer’s control impact return rates? Academic/Practical relevance: Consumer returns raise major questions for manufacturers and retailers because losses due to returns are substantial, but policies that discourage returns have drawbacks. The literature on consumer returns has focused on retailer and purchase attributes but has ignored whether manufacturers can take a proactive role to influence returns. Manufacturers and retailers have an interest in understanding how operational levers influence return rates. Methodology: This work attempts to answer questions about the influence of manufacturing on return rate using detailed operational data from a leading U.S. manufacturer of automotive accessories. We study the impact of key operational levers on return rates using the logistic regression model, while controlling for retailer return policies and numerous product and purchase attributes. Results: We find that increased worker specialization helps reduce return rates but the impact is U-shaped. Increased workload levels in production result in higher return rates whereas product personalization leads to lower return rates. Managerial implications: Our results suggest that manufacturers can help reduce return rates by carefully managing production characteristics and by personalizing the product. These levers can be used in addition to more commonly used levers to deter returns, such as strict return policies which could potentially dampen sales. We outline an approach that managers can use to understand the impact of operational levers on return rates.
Business,Economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?