Abstract:The focus of this paper is on sense-making and the use of real-world knowledge in mathematical modeling in schools. Arguments are put forward that classroom word problem solving is more—and also less—than the analysis of subject-matter structures. Students easily “solve” stereotyped, even unsolvable, problems without any regard to the constraints of factual reality. Mathematics learning in schools is inseparable not only from the materials employed, but from the macro- and microcultural web of practices within the social context of schooling. It represents, beyond the insightful activity of ideal problem solving, a type of socio-cognitive skill.The two experiments reported replicate and extend a study by Verschaffel, De Corte, and Lasure (1994). In the first experiment, a list of standard problems that could be solved by straightforward use of arithmetic operations, and a parallel list of problems which were problematic with respect to realistic mathematical modeling, were administered to fourth and fifth graders. In the second experiment, a similar list of problematic problems was presented to seventh graders under three socio-contextual conditions varying in the degree to which the pupils were told or signaled that the problems were more difficult to solve than it seemed at first or that they even could be unsolvable. The result of both studies was that most pupils “solved” a significant part of the unsolvable problems without evincing “realistic reactions”. This overall finding is discussed with respect to three issues: 1.(i) the quality of word problems employed in mathematics education,2.(ii) the culture of teaching and learning, and3.(iii) the more general issue of social rationality in school mathematics problem solving.

Connecting mathematical modeling and social justice through problem posing

Mathematical modeling opportunities reported by secondary mathematics preservice teachers and instructors

Posing Fundable Questions in Mathematics and Science Education

Mathematical Modeling: Issues and Challenges in Mathematics Education and Teaching

Mathematical Modeling Through the Eyes of Elementary and Middle Preservice Teachers

Teaching mathematics from the lens of social justice in a Pakistani classroom

Teaching mathematics through problem posing: insights from an analysis of teaching cases

Problem-Posing Research in Mathematics Education: Some Answered and Unanswered Questions

A Modeling Perspective on the Teaching and Learning of Mathematical Problem Solving

Teaching Mathematics through Problem Posing: four practices for handling students’ posed problems

Middle-Grade Preservice Teachers’ Mathematical Problem Solving and Problem Posing

Multiple Approaches to Problem Posing: Theoretical Considerations Regarding its Definition, Conceptualisation, and Implementation

Learning to Teach Mathematics Through Problem Posing: Teachers’ Beliefs and Performance on Problem Posing

Problem Posing and Its Relationship with Teaching Experience of Elementary School Mathematics Teachers from Ethnic Minority Area in Southwest China

Unboxing mathematics: creating a culture of modeling as critic

Every word problem has a solution—The social rationality of mathematical modeling in schools

Learning to teach through problem posing: A teacher’s journey in a networked teacher−researcher partnership

Examining socio-mathematical norms related to problem posing: a case of a gifted and talented mathematics classroom

Preservice teachers’ mathematical understanding exhibited in problem posing and problem solving

An Examination of Preservice Teachers’ Capacity to Create Mathematical Modeling Problems for Children