Being Well while Doing Well — Distinguishing Necessary from Unnecessary Discomfort in Training

Lisa Rosenbaum

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmms2308228

IF: 158.5

2024-02-08

New England Journal of Medicine

Abstract:Being Well while Doing Well Maintaining medicine’s commitment to excellence while remedying our failures requires distinguishing unnecessary trainee harms from necessary discomforts. Why is it so h...

medicine, general & internal

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Being Well while Doing Well

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmc2403542

IF: 158.5

2024-05-02

New England Journal of Medicine

Abstract:New England Journal of Medicine, Volume 390, Issue 17, Page 1635-1635, May 2, 2024.

medicine, general & internal
Warning bells: How clinicians leverage their discomfort to manage moments of uncertainty

Jonathan S Ilgen,Pim W Teunissen,Anique B H de Bruin,Judith L Bowen,Glenn Regehr

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/medu.14304

Abstract:Objectives: It remains unclear how medical educators can more effectively bridge the gap between trainees' intolerance of uncertainty and the tolerance that experienced physicians demonstrate in practice. Exploring how experienced clinicians experience, appraise and respond to discomfort arising from uncertainty could provide new insights regarding the kinds of behaviours we are trying to help trainees achieve. Methods: We used a constructivist grounded theory approach to explore how emergency medicine faculty experienced, managed and responded to discomfort in settings of uncertainty. Using a critical incident technique, we asked participants to describe case-based experiences of uncertainty immediately following a clinical shift. We used probing questions to explore cognitive, emotional and somatic manifestations of discomfort, how participants had appraised and responded to these cues, and how they had used available resources to act in these moments of uncertainty. Two investigators coded the data line by line using constant comparative analysis and organised transcripts into focused codes. The entire research team discussed relationships between codes and categories, and developed a conceptual framework that reflected the possible relationships between themes. Results: Participants identified varying levels of discomfort in their case descriptions. They described multiple cues alerting them to problems that were evolving in unexpected ways or problems with aspects of management that were beyond their abilities. Discomfort served as a trigger for participants to monitor a situation with greater attention and to proceed more intentionally. It also served as a prompt for participants to think deliberately about the types of human and material resources they might call upon strategically to manage these uncertain situations. Conclusions: Discomfort served as a dynamic means to manage and respond to uncertainty. To be 'tolerant' of uncertainty thus requires clinicians to embrace discomfort as a powerful tool with which to grapple with the complex problems pervasive in clinical practice.
"I never wanted to burn any bridges": discerning between pushing too hard and not enough in trainees' acts of professional resistance

Tasha R Wyatt,Vinayak Jain,TingLan Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-024-10312-8

Abstract:As trainees resist social harm and injustice in medicine, they must navigate the tension between pushing too hard and risking their reputation, or not enough and risking no change at all. We explore the discernment process by examining what trainees attend to moments before and while they are resisting to understand how they manage this tension. We interviewed 18 medical trainees who shared stories of resisting social harm and injustice in their training environments. Interviews were analyzed using open and focused coding using Vinthagen and Johansson's work, which conceptualizes resistance as a dynamic process that includes an individual's subjectivity within a larger system, the context in which they find themselves, and the interactions they have with others. We framed these acts as an individuals' attempt to undermine power, while also being entangled with that power and needing it for their efforts. When deciding on how and whether to resist, trainees underwent a cost-benefit analysis weighing the potential risk against their chances at change. They considered how their acts may influence their relationship with others, whether resisting would damage personal and programmatic reputations, and the embodied and social cues of other stakeholders involved. Trainees undergo a dynamic assessment process in which they analyze large amounts of information to keep themselves safe from potential retaliation. It is by attending to these various factors in their environment that trainees are able to keep their acts professional, and continue to do this challenging work in medical education.
Discovering compassion in medical training: a qualitative study with curriculum leaders, educators, and learners

Charles B Lane,Erin Brauer,Jennifer S Mascaro

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1184032

2023-06-28

Abstract:Background: Compassion is considered a fundamental human capacity instrumental to the creation of medicine and for patient-centered practice and innovations in healthcare. However, instead of nurturing and cultivating institutional compassion, many healthcare providers cite the health system itself as a direct barrier to standard care. The trend of compassion depletion begins with medical students and is often attributed to the culture of undergraduate medical training, where students experience an increased risk of depression, substance use, and suicidality. Objectives: This qualitative study aims to develop a more comprehensive understanding of compassion as it relates to undergraduate medical education. We used focus groups with key stakeholders in medical education to characterize beliefs about the nature of compassion and to identify perceived barriers and facilitators to compassion within their daily responsibilities as educators and students. Methods: Researchers conducted a series of virtual (Zoom) focus groups with stakeholders: Students (N = 14), Small Group Advisors (N = 11), and Medical Curriculum Leaders (N = 4). Transcripts were thematically analyzed using MAXQDA software. Results: Study participants described compassion as being more than empathy, demanding action, and capable of being cultivated. Stakeholders identified self-care, life experiences, and role models as facilitators. The consistently identified barriers to compassion were time constraints, culture, and burnout. Both medical students and those training them agreed on a general definition of compassion and that there are ways to cultivate more of it in their daily professional lives. They also agreed that undergraduate medical education - and the healthcare culture at large - does not deliberately foster compassion and may be directly contributing to its degradation by the content and pedagogies emphasized, the high rates of burnout and futility, and the overwhelming time constraints. Discussion: Intentional instruction in and cultivation of compassion during undergraduate medical education could provide a critical first step for undergirding the professional culture of healthcare with more resilience and warm-hearted concern. Our finding that medical students and those training them agree about what compassion is and that there are specific and actionable ways to cultivate more of it in their professional lives highlights key changes that will promote a more compassionate training environment conducive to the experience and expression of compassion.
Discomfort, Doubt, and the Edge of Learning

Arno K Kumagai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0000000000004588

2022-05-01

Abstract:Discomfort is a constant presence in the practice of medicine and an oft-ignored feature of medical education. Nonetheless, if approached with thoughtfulness, patience, and understanding, discomfort may play a critical role in the education of physicians who practice with excellence, compassion, and justice. Taking Plato's notion of aporia-a moment of discomfort, perplexity, or impasse-as a starting point, the author follows the meandering path of aporia through Western philosophy and educational theory to argue for the importance of discomfort in opening up and orienting perspectives toward just and humanistic practice. Practical applications of this approach include problem-posing questions (from the work of Brazilian education theorist Paulo Freire), exercises to "make strange" beliefs and assumptions that are taken for granted, and the use of stories-especially stories without endings-all of which may prompt reflection and dialogical exchange. Framing this type of teaching and learning in Russian psychologist L.S. Vygotsky's theories of development, the author proposes that mentorship and dialogical interactions may help learners to navigate through moments of discomfort and uncertainty and extend the edge of learning. This approach may give birth to a zone of proximal development that is enriched with explorations of self, others, and the world.
Strategies of Well-being Training and Resilience

Dustin M Walters,Michael Maddaus

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.thorsurg.2024.04.006

Abstract:As cardiothoracic surgeons, we face frequent challenges to our well-being and our ability to function as our best selves. Building personal resilience is an important way to help us manage these challenges. Here, the authors outline the scope of the problem, the consequences of burnout, and offer 4 strategies to train ourselves to be more resilient: (1) Pursuit of fulfillment, (2) Cultivation of community and belonging, (3) Mitigation of microstresses and avoiding feelings of overwhelm, and (4) Building a "resilience bank account."
"A clean slate": Insights for improving remediation from the perspectives of underperforming surgical trainees

Kathryn McLeod,Robyn Woodward-Kron,Prem Rashid,Debra Nestel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amjsurg.2024.115942

2024-08-30

Abstract:Background: Remediation frameworks have centered around perspectives of educators. The aim of this study is to explore the insights proposed by surgical trainees to improve remediation processes. Methods: This qualitative study used semi-structured interviews with 11 doctors who have experienced formal remediation as a surgical trainee. We used reflexive thematic analysis on transcribed interviews. Results: Trainees recommended creating environments that safeguarded their well-being. Examples include trainee-led peer support groups and external mentors. Feedback conversations and remediation plans were flagged as needing improvement. Opportunities for forward planning for successful remediation were suggested including learning plans, program evaluation and aligning training program structure with expectations. Conclusions: These findings about trainees' insights on improving remediation highlighted the need for further emotional support for trainees. Supervisors need further support with feedback conversations and remediation plans. Actively seeking out trainee perspectives and integrating their recommendations when designing remediation processes should improve outcomes.
Am I providing reasonable care? A question to help doctors avoid the perfection trap

Zaid Al-Najjar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2143

2024-10-02

BMJ

Abstract:I was recently talking with a colleague about a clinical pathway in our practice that needed review and improvement. Aware of the danger of overthinking what needed to change, I asked them, "Is what is currently being offered reasonable?"I don't know how this question makes you feel, but as doctors we generally don't want to offer care that's "reasonable" or, to paraphrase the paediatrician and psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott, "good enough." Even just writing down or saying that "I offer a reasonable standard of care" feels uncomfortable. Most of the time we want to offer perfection, yet this can be incompatible with the environments and systems many of us work in.When our default expectation is perfection, it can make providing reasonable care and treatment feel like failing. But if you think about it, is it really that bad to provide a reasonable level of care for our patients? Isn't being "good...

medicine, general & internal
The Spiritual Works of Mercy as a Tool to Prevent Burnout in Medical Trainees

Paul M. Shaniuk

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0024363920920400

2020-05-07

The Linacre Quarterly

Abstract:Burnout is highly prevalent among physicians and is associated with negative patient outcomes. Furthermore, medical training is a particularly vulnerable time as studies show that medical students, residents, and fellows experience burnout and emotional exhaustion at higher rates than both the general population and physicians in practice. Multiple recent studies have demonstrated the practice of religion and spirituality to be protective against burnout in trainees. Can Catholic academic physicians transfer these protective benefits of religion and spirituality to their trainees, who are at the highest risk, and who may or may not share their faith? An ancient Catholic tradition, the Seven Spiritual Works of Mercy, may hold the key. The Spiritual Works of Mercy are listed by the US Conference of Catholic Bishops as Counseling the Doubtful, Instructing the Ignorant, Admonishing the Sinner, Comforting the Sorrowful, Forgiving Injuries, Bearing Wrongs Patiently, and Praying for the Living and the Dead. Using this as a framework, examples of evidenced-based actions from the literature that have been shown to either prevent burnout or to improve the day-to-day experience of medical trainees were discussed. Examples include encouraging trainees to express doubts or to debrief after difficult and saddening cases. Academic physicians can provide instruction, feedback, or admonishment; demonstrate forgiveness of errors; and model the way in bearing wrongs patiently, all while uplifting their trainees in prayer. The Spiritual Works of Mercy can thus become a framework for academic physicians to uplift their trainees’ spirits and potentially prevent against burnout. Summary: Burnout is highly prevalent in medical students and in doctors during their residency or fellowship training, but multiple studies have shown regular practice of religion and spirituality to be protective against burnout. The Seven Spiritual Works of Mercy (Counsel the Doubtful, Instruct the Ignorant, Admonish the Sinner, Comfort the Sorrowful, Forgive All Injuries, Bear Wrongs Patiently and Pray for the Living and the Dead) provide a framework of powerful examples for teaching physicians, particularly Catholic teaching physicians, to uplift their students and potentially transfer this benefit to reduce their students’ risk for burnout.
Psychological Distress in the Era of Psychological Safety

Alissa Zeglin,Madeline McCarthy,Susan Nedorost,Michael Dell,Lia Logio

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11606-024-08893-6

2024-07-01

Abstract:There has been a growing disconnect between learners and educators within medical education. As the landscape of medical education has been altered post-pandemic and cultural shifts favor "safe spaces," we sought to explore the tension that exists between a sense of safety and the discomfort inherent within the learning process. Through separate focus groups conducted with trainees and faculty, a common theme emerged: a sense of vulnerability. Trainees feel a strong sense of vulnerability when receiving feedback, particularly when given in public or when expectations were unclear. Educators feel a sense of vulnerability that their feedback will be interpreted as "retaliatory teaching." This sense of vulnerability was heightened in situations that emphasized the tension between personal well-being vs altruism, safe spaces vs accountability to high standards, and advocacy for system change vs power hierarchy. We must acknowledge this vulnerability and the resulting tensions that can ensue due to the competing commitments of medical training. By cultivating a culture of mutual growth and respect, we can create a learning environment that embodies the highest standards of medicine.
Gaining Respect and Mitigating Risk: A Qualitative Exploration of How New Attendings Navigate Interpersonal Relationships with Recent Resident Peers

Cameryn C Garrett,Hannah Robinson,Jacob David,Brian Utz,Michelle B Azimov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/pme.1396

2024-10-03

Abstract:Background: Physicians moving through training experience changes in personal and professional relationships, which can increase stress, uncertainty, and burnout. Social connection can be an important resource but can introduce complexity and conflict. This study aimed to explore how early-career attendings navigate and manage changing organizational and friendship roles with recent resident peers (near-peers) through this critical transition. Methods: We conducted a reflexive thematic analysis of interviews with early-career attendings working with near-peers from the same institution where they trained. Twenty three of 27 (85%) eligible attendings from two United States health systems participated in semi-structured interviews between April and June 2023. Results: Familiarity from working at the same institution where new attendings completed training made it more difficult to command authority. Early-career attendings at times struggled with insecurities about their ability to fulfill their new role and challenges from others in recognizing their new attending identity. These tensions could heighten emotions in the clinical setting and spill over into relationships with residents outside the workplace, impacting social lives and well-being. Early-career attendings engaged in strategies to manage the social realm of their transition with near-peers, including prioritizing their organizational role in the clinical setting and mitigating risks to their professional reputation by creating stronger boundaries between their personal and professional lives. Conclusions: This study provides new insight into how attendings navigate changing personal and professional relationships with recent resident peers and offers strategies on how to manage the social realm of this liminal transition.
Uncovering the hidden medical curriculum through a pedagogy of discomfort

Julie M Aultman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-004-4455-2

Abstract:What lies beneath the formal or overt curriculum may impair students' professional growth and development, including their ability to foster genuine relationships with patients and others, and may contribute to the inadvertent, often negative attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors expressed by medical students and witnessed by educators within and external to the classroom environment. To understand the impact a hidden medical curriculum has on both students and educators, I look at one particular model often used in medical education--the physician-patient relationship. I show how this therapeutic relationship ought to be understood through a pedagogy of discomfort, a model developed by Megan Boler (Feeling Power; Emotions and Education, 1999), as a way to uncover the hidden curriculum as it engages students in a collective, critical discourse through which their sense of self in relation to others becomes the groundwork for their professional and moral development. Understanding the physician-patient relationship through a pedagogy of discomfort also teachers students how to critically think about the different values and beliefs held by physicians and patients and how to begin to recognize themselves as physicians in relation to their patients and others.
From distress to detachment: exploring how providing care for stigmatized patients influences the moral development of medical trainees

Lisa X. Liu,Mark Goldszmidt,Sara Calvert,Sarah Burm,Jacqueline Torti,Sayra Cristancho,Javeed Sukhera

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-022-10125-7

IF: 3.629

2022-05-30

Advances in Health Sciences Education

Abstract:In acute hospital settings, medical trainees are often confronted with moral challenges and negative emotions when caring for complex and structurally vulnerable patients. These challenges may influence the long term moral development of medical trainees and have significant implications for future clinical practice. Despite the importance of moral development to medical education, the topic is still relatively under-explored. To gain a deeper understanding of moral development in trainees, we conducted a qualitative exploration of how caring for a stigmatized population influences their moral development. Data were collected from 48 medical trainees, including observational field notes, supplemental interviews, and medical documentation from inpatient units of two urban teaching hospitals in a Canadian context. Utilizing a practice-based approach which draws on constructivist grounded theory, we conducted constant comparative coding and analysis. We found that caring for stigmatized populations appeared to trigger frustration in medical trainees, which often perpetuated feelings of futility as well as avoidance behaviours. Additionally, hospital policies, the physical learning environment, variability in supervisory practices, and perceptions of judgment and mistrust all negatively influenced moral development and contributed to apathy and moral detachment which has implications for the future. Recognizing the dynamic and uncertain nature of care for stigmatized patients, and addressing the influence of structural and material factors provide an opportunity to support moral experiences within clinical training, and to improve inequities.

education & educational research,education, scientific disciplines,health care sciences & services
Is there health in wellness?

S Levenstein

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/00004836-199609000-00004

Abstract:In the last 20 years, patient autonomy has vastly increased and a "well-being" movement has flourished, with great benefits but with definite drawbacks as well. Exaggeration of the individual's potential for prevention and self-healing can foster a crude psychological reductionism that hampers potential for subtle etiologic understanding and may weaken research, as well as creating a tendency to blame the victim. Probing of the health effects of any activity before engaging in it can lead to healthier-than-thouness and a fear of living. The well-being movement tends to ignore social causes of disease in favor of individual ones and therefore to disregard a need for social remedies. Both theory and practice can be contaminated by economic motives: Medicine is expensive, meditation is cheap. The chasm between the "mind-body" school and the dominant medical model may have widened as some holistically minded individuals, finding a haven in the well-being movement, give up on affecting the medical mainstream. Thus, the advance of holistic medicine has aided in conceptualizing the health-illness continuum, in understanding pathogenesis, and in discovering new preventive and therapeutic tools, but its emphasis on internal causes and therapies should not be allowed to detract resources from the equally important ones lying outside the realm of lifestyle.
Physician Path to Wellness. A Qualitative Investigation of Self-Reported Strategies to Shift from Detrimental Health to Optimal Wellness

Ross Sizemore,Martin Huecker,Jacob Shreffler,Mallory Zaino,Alyssa Thomas,Justin Kelley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/15598276221114314

2022-07-18

American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine

Abstract:American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine, Ahead of Print. Background: A healthy physician performs better clinically and provides superior care to patients than a physician struggling with burnout.Objective: The purpose of this study is to assess the physician perception of "health" and "burnout," to identify successful wellness-promoting behaviors, and to build a model characterizing the successful transition from poor health to wellness.Methods: Utilizing a qualitative approach, the team conducted one-on-one, in-depth, semi-structured interviews with physicians from different specialties. Questions focused on behaviors, beliefs, and system changes that facilitated their transition from poor health/burnout to wellness. Interviews were recorded and responses qualitatively coded from a set of definitions of wellness and burnout. These coded responses were quantified, and code prevalence was analyzed.Results: Fourteen physicians completed interviews. The codebook consisted of 74 total themes, with nine occurring in more than 10 (71%) of the interviews. Most themes yielded to categories of Wellness, Unwell, and Burnout, with several themes related to individual agency in facilitating wellness. Highly prevalent themes included support systems, nutrition, exercise, and cognitive health. Subjects generally described comprehensive approaches to successfully transitioning to wellness.Conclusion: This study describes strategies for the successful transition to wellness: physician-level factors such as a healthy support system, maintaining a healthy lifestyle, and developing consistent daily routines. These findings support the importance of physician autonomy and individual-level wellness-promoting strategies for a physician's transition to wellness. More research should investigate the overall effect of individual-level strategies versus system-level interventions.
Well-Being and Professional Fulfillment in Mohs Surgeons: An Explanatory Sequential Mixed-Method Design Study

Charlene Lam,Yesul Kim,Heather J Costigan,Heather Stuckey,Allison T Vidimos,Elizabeth M Billingsley,John G Albertini,Jeffrey J Miller,Tait D Shanafelt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/DSS.0000000000003801

2023-07-01

Abstract:Background: There are limited data evaluating specific themes of well-being and professional fulfillment in Mohs surgeons. Objective: To identify factors that drive occupational distress and those that promote well-being and professional fulfillment among Mohs surgeons. Methods: This is an explanatory sequential mixed-method study, using semistructured individual interviews. Common drivers of physician well-being and fulfillment were identified based on the independent assessment of the coding in the interview transcripts. Results: This study reports the following qualitative themes: (1) gratitude for the chosen profession and relationships, (2) unrealistic standards of perfection that may have contributed to past career success but are unattainable and create emotional burden, and (3) ability to practice in a manner aligned with personal values promotes professional fulfillment. Conclusion: This study suggests that gratitude, self-compassion, and ability to practice in a manner aligned with personal values promote well-being and professional fulfillment in Mohs surgeons. Notably, we found that unrealistic standards of perfection and personal-organization practice incongruences contribute to burnout.
Being kind in unkind spaces: a qualitative examination of how medical educators and first year medical students perceive empathy training

Sarah D. C. Harvey,Clare L. Stacey

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fsoc.2023.1272357

2024-01-19

Frontiers in Sociology

Abstract:Introduction It has become de rigueur for healthcare systems to tout their ability to provide compassionate medical care that addresses the emotional as well as physical needs of patients. Not surprisingly, then, there is considerable pressure on medical schools to train their students to be empathic. Existing literature on empathy training in medicine tends to focus on how to build emotional intelligence in individual trainees, largely ignoring the sociocultural factors that contribute to or thwart empathy development in medical school. Additionally, research tends to examine student perspectives, with little attention given to medical educators and their viewpoints. Methods In this paper, we adopt an “emotion practice” framework and utilize an inductive descriptive study design to qualitatively consider how first year medical students ( N = 23) and their instructors ( N = 9) perceive empathy training at a site we call Midtown Medical School. Results and discussion We find that both groups have an understanding of empathic capital but differ in their beliefs about the utility and legitimacy of this capital. Both educators and students also recognize the limitations of standardized empathy curriculum but do not agree on the implications of such rote learning. Finally, students and instructors alike find the hidden curriculum of medical school to be antithetical to empathy development, concurring that it is difficult to cultivate empathy in spaces where biomedical coursework is prioritized over social–emotional learning. In short, both groups find it difficult to be kind in an unkind place .
Awakening Change—Embracing Disability in Medical Training

Kelsey D. Biddle

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2024.3187

2024-10-08

JAMA Internal Medicine

Abstract:"Have you ever used a uterine manipulator?" the resident asks, gesturing to the narrow space between the patient's legs. "Have a seat." I hesitate, then cautiously sit, unsure if I can stay awake without side steps and calf raises. I place my hand on the black plastic handle and hope no one senses my unease as the resident demonstrates, steering my wrist like a mechanical joystick. "We'll be back here on the robot," announces the surgeon, gesturing to the surgical console at the room's edge. "Holler if you have questions."

medicine, general & internal
The Limits of Cognitive Reappraisal: Changing Pain Valence, but not Persistence, during a Resistance Exercise Task

Catherine J. Berman,Julia D. O’Brien,Zachary Zenko,Dan Ariely

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph16193739

IF: 4.614

2019-10-04

International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health

Abstract:Physiological discomfort is commonly cited as a barrier for initiating and persisting with exercise. Although individuals may think of physiological discomfort as determined by physical sensations, it can also be influenced by cognitive and emotional factors. We explored the impacts of interpreting the purpose of pain as a sign of muscle building (helpful) vs. a sign of muscle tearing and possible injury (harmful) and tested the effect of cognitive reappraisals, or shifting interpretations of pain, on exercise persistence and the subjective experience of discomfort during exercise. Seventy-eight participants were randomized to listen to voice recordings that framed exercise-related pain as helpful vs. harmful before participating in a standard muscular endurance test using the YMCA protocol. Although the two experimental groups did not differ in the overall number of resistance training repetitions achieved, participants who were asked to think about the benefits (rather than the negative consequences) of pain reported less negative pain valence during exercise. Thus, the experience of pain was influenced by appraisals of the meaning of pain, but differences in pain valence did not impact exercise persistence. Theoretical implications and applications for affect-based exercise interventions are discussed.

public, environmental & occupational health,environmental sciences
When Fulfilling a Professional Obligation Causes Moral Distress: A New Evaluative Approach

Daniel T. Kim,Wayne Shelton,Linda Breslin,Megan K. Applewhite

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/08850666241285861

2024-09-20

Journal of Intensive Care Medicine

Abstract:Journal of Intensive Care Medicine, Ahead of Print. PurposeThe term 'moral distress' was coined by Andrew Jameton to name the anguish that clinicians feel when they cannot pursue what they judge to be right because of institutional constraints. We argue that moral distress in critical care should also be addressed as a function of the constraints of ethics and propose an evaluative approach to the experience considering its implications for professional identity.MethodWe build on a selective review of the literature and analyze a paradigmatic example of moral distress, namely, clinicians who feel compelled to perform procedures on patients that seem futile. Such cases are commonly cited by clinicians as among the most morally distressing.ResultsOur analysis shows that (1) physicians' experiences of moral distress can stem not only from toxic workplace cultures and institutional constraints on their time and resources for patient care but also from the limits of ethical reasoning and (2) an emotion-based evaluative approach to analyzing moral distress is needed to address its hazards for professional identity.ConclusionWe propose a new evaluative approach to moral distress with implications for professional identity and the need for institutional education and support.

critical care medicine

Being Well while Doing Well — Distinguishing Necessary from Unnecessary Discomfort in Training

Being Well while Doing Well

Warning bells: How clinicians leverage their discomfort to manage moments of uncertainty

"I never wanted to burn any bridges": discerning between pushing too hard and not enough in trainees' acts of professional resistance

Discovering compassion in medical training: a qualitative study with curriculum leaders, educators, and learners

Discomfort, Doubt, and the Edge of Learning

Strategies of Well-being Training and Resilience

"A clean slate": Insights for improving remediation from the perspectives of underperforming surgical trainees

Am I providing reasonable care? A question to help doctors avoid the perfection trap

The Spiritual Works of Mercy as a Tool to Prevent Burnout in Medical Trainees

Psychological Distress in the Era of Psychological Safety

Gaining Respect and Mitigating Risk: A Qualitative Exploration of How New Attendings Navigate Interpersonal Relationships with Recent Resident Peers

Uncovering the hidden medical curriculum through a pedagogy of discomfort

From distress to detachment: exploring how providing care for stigmatized patients influences the moral development of medical trainees

Is there health in wellness?

Physician Path to Wellness. A Qualitative Investigation of Self-Reported Strategies to Shift from Detrimental Health to Optimal Wellness

Well-Being and Professional Fulfillment in Mohs Surgeons: An Explanatory Sequential Mixed-Method Design Study

Being kind in unkind spaces: a qualitative examination of how medical educators and first year medical students perceive empathy training

Awakening Change—Embracing Disability in Medical Training

The Limits of Cognitive Reappraisal: Changing Pain Valence, but not Persistence, during a Resistance Exercise Task

When Fulfilling a Professional Obligation Causes Moral Distress: A New Evaluative Approach