Influence of Child Independence, Gender, and Birthdate on Kindergarten Teachers' Recommendations for Retention

David A. Bergin,Vicki L. Osburn,John R. Cryan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02568549609594898
1996-06-01
Journal of Research in Childhood Education
Abstract:The purpose of this study was to investigate three factors other than achievement or competence that might influence kindergarten teachers when making placement decisions for the children in their classes. Hypothetical student profiles were sent to 600 kindergarten teachers throughout the state of Ohio; 252 teachers responded. Eight profiled children were described as having successfully completed the academic requirements of kindergarten (thus academic achievement was held constant), but they varied by age (August versus February birthday), gender, and level of independence. Teachers were not significantly more likely to recommend retention for boys, nor were they significantly more likely to recommend retention for August children, though the trend was toward retaining younger children. Teachers were more likely to recommend retention for children who were described as dependent and somewhat immature. Older teachers were more likely to recommend retention. In their written comments, teachers who recommended retention most often mentioned low independence and immaturity as reasons.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?