FDI in the Banking Sector : Why borrowing costs fall while spread proxies increase
Katheryn Niles Russ,Burkhard Schipper,Alan Taylor,Diego Valderrama,Carlos Vegh
2008-01-01
Abstract:It is a well known quandry that when countries open their
nancial sectors, foreign-owned banks appear to bring superior e¢ ciency to their host markets but also charge higher markups on borrowed funds than their domestically owned rivals. We construct a general equilibrium model of foreign direct investment (FDI) in the banking sector to capture this dichotomy, assessing its welfare implications for opening the
nancial sector to foreign participation. Using heterogeneous, imperfectly competitive lenders, the model illustrates that FDI can cause markups (the net interest margins commonly used to proxy lending-to-deposit rate spreads) to increase and at the same time cause the interest rates banks charge borrowers to fall. The phenomenon is especially relevant for less developed countries where it can be harder to implement the parents technology and for countries where there are more limitations on entry by domestic banks. In the model, borrowing costs fall on average under liberalization due to improved e¢ ciency among lenders, increasing consumption and welfare in both countries. The authors thank Joshua Aizenman, Andy Bernard, Paul Bergin, Colin Cameron, Jonathan Eaton, Linda Goldberg, Ignacio Hernando, Òscar Jordà, José Manuel Marqués, Doug Miller, Marc Muendler, Antonio Navas, Burkhard Schipper, Alan Taylor, Diego Valderrama, Carlos Vegh, Leon Wegge, and especially Viktors Stebunovs for helpful comments, as well as participants in seminars at the 2008 EEA-ESEM, 2008 Simposio de Análisis Económico, 2008 Canadian Economics Association Summer Meetings, CEMFI MadMac, 2008 ITI NBER Summer Institute, 2008 Spring Midwest International Trade and Theory Meetings, 2008 Spring Midwest Macro Meetings, 2008 North American Summer Meetings of the Econometrics Society, UC Davis and UC San Diego. Beatriz de Blas acknowledges
nancial support from SEJ2005-05831 project of the Spanish MEC, CCG08-UAM/HUM-4438 and the hospitality of the Economics Department at UCD while developing part of this work. Corresponding Email: knruss@ucdavis.edu