Human Communication Research Issn 0360-3989 Parasocial Interaction and Parasocial Relationship: Conceptual Clarification and a Critical Assessment of Measures

Tilo Hartmann,Sarah F. Rosaen,Jayson L. Dibble

Abstract:Parasocial interaction and parasocial relationship are often conflated conceptually and methodologically, leaving researchers unclear as to which concept is being tapped. This research clarifies these concepts and experimentally compares the most common measure of parasocial interaction, the Parasocial Interaction Scale (PSI-Scale), with a newer measure, the Experience of Parasocial Interaction Scale (EPSI-Scale). Participants (N = 383) viewed a brief videorecording of a woman who either bodily addressed the viewer or not, then completed a questionnaire. The EPSI-Scale was a better measure of parasocial interaction, understood as a within-viewing experience of mutual awareness, whereas the PSI-Scale may measure short-or long-term liking, or something else. To avoid conceptual and empirical confusion, researchers must choose measures with greater care. Parasocial interaction is a concept that remains popular among those who study media and media effects. Originally put forth by Horton and Wohl (1956), parasocial interaction referred to a media user's reaction to a media performer such that the media user perceives the performer as an intimate conversational partner. A sense of conversational give-and-take often emerges during viewing and is strongest when the media performer bodily addresses the viewer through the camera. This early work by Horton and Wohl also alluded to a related concept, the parasocial relationship, which is a more enduring relationship that a media user forms with a mediated performer. While parasocial interaction is restricted to the viewing episode, a parasocial relationship can extend beyond any single viewing episode.

Psychology