Abstract:Introduction: Biodiversity loss poses a significant environmental challenge, particularly in aquatic ecosystems. The advent of environmental DNA (eDNA) sampling technology offers a promising tool for monitoring biological communities with purported high efficiency. Yet, its efficacy compared to traditional sampling methods remains underexplored, especially in fish diversity research. Methods: This study conducted a comparative analysis of fish diversity and distribution across 29 sampling points within the rivers of the Changqing Nature Reserve, Central China, employing both eDNA techniques and traditional sampling methods. Results: A total of 46 unique fish species were identified through this comprehensive approach. eDNA sampling detected 34 species, surpassing the 22 species identified by traditional methods. Interestingly, 10 species were detected by both methods, while traditional methods exclusively identified 12 species not detected by eDNA, and eDNA uniquely identified an additional 24 species. Despite eDNA's broader species detection range, traditional sampling methods typically yielded higher Shannon diversity index values. Both β-diversity indices (Bray-Curtis and Jaccard) and multivariate analyses (NMDS and PCoA) were applied, revealing no significant statistical differences in biodiversity measurement between the two sampling methods. Discussion: The findings suggest that while eDNA sampling excels in identifying a wider range of species, it does not significantly outperform traditional methods in overall biodiversity assessment. By integrating both methodologies, this study demonstrates a more comprehensive and precise assessment of riverine biodiversity, underscoring the benefits of a synergistic approach for enhancing species detection and understanding distribution patterns. The combined methodology notably improves alpha diversity evaluations, particularly regarding Shannon diversity and Berger-Parker dominance. This integrated approach advocates for the amalgamation of data from both eDNA and conventional methods, fostering a robust and accurate biodiversity appraisal.

Fish community assessment with eDNA metabarcoding: effects of sampling design and bioinformatic filtering

Assessment of Fish Communities Using Environmental DNA: Effect of Spatial Sampling Design in Lentic Systems of Different Sizes

eDNA metabarcoding in lakes to quantify influences of landscape features and human activity on aquatic invasive species prevalence and fish community diversity

Environmental DNA metabarcoding of fish communities in a small hydropower dam reservoir: a comparison between the eDNA approach and established fishing methods

Environmental DNA (eDNA) as a tool for assessing fish biomass: A review of approaches and future considerations for resource surveys

Comparison of Environmental DNA Metabarcoding and a Traditional Survey Method for Assessing Fish Diversity and Distribution Along Salinity Gradient in an Urban Brackish Reservoir, China

Effect of environmental DNA sampling resolution in detecting nearshore fish biodiversity compared to capture surveys

Environmental DNA detection of rare and invasive fish species in two Great Lakes tributaries

Bridging the gap: The integration of eDNA techniques and traditional sampling in fish diversity analysis

Relating target fish DNA concentration to community composition analysis in freshwater fish via metabarcoding

Fishing for Fish Environmental DNA: Ecological Applications, Methodological Considerations, Surveying Designs, and Ways Forward

Maximizing fish detection with eDNA metabarcoding

Determining an effective sampling method for eDNA metabarcoding: a case study for fish biodiversity monitoring in a small, natural river

Using Optimal Environmental DNA Method to Improve the Fish Diversity Survey-From Laboratory to Aquatic Life Reserve

Nearshore fish diversity changes with sampling method and human disturbance: Comparing eDNA metabarcoding and seine netting along the Upper St. Lawrence River

Environmental DNA metabarcoding primers for freshwater fish detection and quantification: In silico and in tanks

Detection of introduced and resident marine species using environmental DNA metabarcoding of sediment and water

A comparative analysis of eDNA metabarcoding and field surveys: Exploring freshwater plant communities in rivers

Insights into the representativeness of biodiversity assessment in large reservoir through eDNA metabarcoding

eDNA metabarcoding revealed differential structures of aquatic communities in a dynamic freshwater ecosystem shaped by habitat heterogeneity

Edna Metabarcoding in Zooplankton Improves the Ecological Status Assessment of Aquatic Ecosystems